Affordable Wedding Caterers in Manhattan, NY

Affordable Wedding Caterers in Manhattan, NY

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


124 Wedding Caterers in Manhattan, NY

Up to $5,800
Clear
Quick responder
MAHFY Catering 

5.0

  • Starts at $2,500
  • Serves Manhattan, NY

We are MAHFY Catering and we're dedicated to delivering one-of-a-kind experiences for your special celebration. Our talented chefs are passionate about serving our delicious fusion of world-famous flavors that will have your guests asking for seconds. With a focus on using high quality ingredients, tried-and-proven recipes and elegant presentations, MAHFY Catering aims to exceed your expectations from start to finish.

Aiyana and Keith were amazing from being to end. I hired them as the caterers for my wedding (100ppl). Their communication was timely and professional. This is one of the reasons we chose MAHFY over other catering vendors. We were able to do a tasting, which we made it into a whole date night. It was really good. We love their food and they have such positive energy. They helped us customize our menu. All requirements on their end were met for our venue. Last minute (two weeks prior) I needed extra help with clean up and they agreed to get more staff. My event decorator raved about how helpful they were with setup. They were early and ready to go! The cocktail hour and reception food was good and we received a lot of compliments from our guest. We also hired them to bartend the wedding and drinks were great as well. Clean up was fast and to the point. All staff were helpful, kind and professional. I cannot thank MAHFY for catering my wedding and making it a memorable night for us and our guest.
Alyna, 3 months ago
Quick responder
Renegade Outpost 

5.0

  • Starts at $4,000
  • Serves Manhattan, NY
  • Offer

Renegade Outpost is a full service event planning and chef services company. We've been in business for 7 years and have been working with Thumbtack. We have been hired more than 290 times and have 160 5-star reviews. We offer logistical services as well as day/of coordination and securing rentals. Our "rolodex" includes many of the best vendors for all your event needs. Making your job easier is our highest priority. Wonderful food always begins with amazing ingredients, especially produce. We source directly from local farmers, we work with an organic butcher, a wild fish monger and importers of select cheese and specialty products.

Awarded Best of Zola
Chef Ellen goes above and beyond. We had a backyard wedding for 117 guests with passed hors d’oeuvres, appetizer station (a surprise by chef!), sit down plated entrees, as well as finger sized desserts! We had a tasting prior to decide the final menu. The food is phenomenal- chef used both our indoor kitchen as well as our garage for food prep/cooking. Not only does she supply food and server staff, but has a plethora of vendor connections for all wedding necessities- floral decor, bar tending staff and decor, linen decor, tent/table/chair vendors, etc! Transparent pricing- never felt shortchanged. We talked on the phone often, going through various in depth details that by the pictures, you can see were worth the extra time! Will be using chef again for our baby gender reveal party!
Leanna & J., 3 years ago
Abigail Kirsch Catering 

5.0

  • Serves Manhattan, NY

The seeds of the business go back to the 1960s when Abigail started a cooking school from the basement of her home. Her entrepreneurial spirit and early success drove her to quickly expand the school to a retail outlet, and few years later, her husband, Bob, sold his company to join her in launching the catering business. Their son, Jim, joined the couple in 1980 and has been running the business with Partner & Chef Alison Awerbuch since the early 2000s. Through the years, the DNA of Abigail Kirsch has never changed. Rooted in the belief that, “We are only as good as our last event,” its culture centers on creativity, planning and flawless execution. The company’s mission is to execute events in which the client feels like a guest and guests feel as though they are in someone’s home.

Abigail Kirsch is expert at what they do. They are not just a venue or a caterer, they are trustworthy partners who do not miss a beat, provide so much value to their couples and clients, and are truly amazing people. You'll miss them after the wedding! What struck me most, in all the quotes I've seen whether for work or my own wedding, Abigail Kirsch makes it easy for you. Their costs make sense, there are no fees to be figured out on your own, they are clear and diligent from the get-go and through to the very end.
Danielle & C., 5 years ago
KGFare Catering & Events 

5.0

  • Serves Manhattan, NY

In 2008 Josh Griffiths and Peter Killy decided it was time to create without compromise. They launched KG Fare, offering fun, dynamic and memorable full-service catering and event experiences. Hospitality without the attitude. Entertaining curations that raise the bar for food and drinks.

We enjoyed collaborating with KG Fare on our dream wedding menu. They were flexible and supportive of our wedding vision, especially during the COVID period. They spent time with us to go over every single detail from the texture and flavor of the food to safety measures to the overall set up of tables, decorations and more. Weeks leading up to our big, special event, we were in constant communication via phone and email. On the big day, Peter and Josh and the crew were super attentive to us and our guests. The food was such a hit that our guests kept talking about it for days after the event. To this day, we still crave for everything on our menu because the food was scrumptious. KG Fare's check went beyond our expectation and made sure everything we talked about during the food tasting was incorporated on the actual event! We would work with KG Fare again in any future events that requires catering! Thank you!
Angel & D., 4 years ago
Quick responder
Alexandra Dettori Catering & Events 

5.0

  • Starts at $4,000
  • Serves Manhattan, NY

Alexandra Dettori Catering & Events is a full service boutique caterer focused on sustainability, seasonality and using locally sourced ingredients across a variety of cuisines. We believe in getting the best ingredients available and making everything from scratch. We strive to delight with incredible food, crafted beverages and attentive service. Our team will ensure your wedding is truly exceptional! In addition to the food, we are happy to offer front of the house staffing, bar service, assist with rentals, set up and clean up. Our team will connect with you to tailor our offering and match your vision.

I have worked with Alex at AD Catering for multiple big events. Both as a photographer and florist myself, I am extremely visual and specific about how things are presented and AD blows it out of the water. While looks are important, for the actual product (food and delivery) to be such high quality is very rare and they always deliver. Alex has amazing taste and styling skills when it comes to design details. She is extremely professional to work with and her team is super friendly and reliable. AD Catering is truly unique from any catering and planning service I have ever worked with before and anyone would be so lucky to work with them!!
Leatal, 5 years ago
Quick responder
Red Oyster USA 

5.0

  • Serves Manhattan, NY

We are a boutique catering business, specialized in Oystertaining people. Our Oystertainers open fresh oysters on the spot while entertaining your guests. The oysters come from carefully selected oysterfarms in the Northern East coast of US/Canada. With their outgoing personality, our Oystertainers know how to persuade almost anybody to eat oysters. The founder, Matijn Wijn, started the company 20 years ago in the Netherlands. He is driven by a passion for oysters and when he introduced Oystertainment® it was an overnight success. We also run oyster bars at world leading art fairs like Art Basel and TEFAF. Let's Oystertain you!

If you have the opportunity to book Red Oyster USA for your event you 100% should! First off the booking experience was above and beyond with customer service, answering all of my questions promptly and with ease. My husband and I renewed our vows on a rooftop in New York City December 30. My husband and a lot of our guests enjoy oysters so I thought this would be the perfect addition to our reception! We had the pleasure of having Sophia as our Oystertainer for the evening. She was AMAZING!!! She was extremely friendly and helpful! I was not much of an oyster person before, but she had me try them a couple of different ways and I did find one that actually worked really well for me. If it wasn’t for her knowledge and guiding I probably would’ve never tried them and now I am a fan! The Oystertainer was really another amazing staple to our evening and I am so glad we were able to book them. I would book them each time I had an event if I was given the opportunity, I highly suggest you do the same!!!! You won’t regret it!!! Now I will have to wait until they expand to Oklahoma (hint,hint) to book again!
Starr J., 5 years ago
KD Event Group 

5.0

  • Starts at $2,750
  • Serves Manhattan, NY

KD Event Group is comprised of experienced and talented hospitality professional with 30+ years of NYC events in their portfolios. We actively partner with only the most experienced and respected event and culinary professionals in the Tristate area. With a proven track record of delivering hospitality focused client relations within the NYC catering industry, KD Event Group is not just another catering company. Offering a wide range of services from full service wedding catering to corporate event catering , KD Event Group brings its personalized attention to every detail, creating thoughtful and inspired events.

I was beyond pleased working with KD Event Group for my wedding! From the first call with Kelly, I felt supported and that she really cared about helping to create this amazing experience for my guests. My partner and I are foodies and Kelly completely understood that right away! The communication from the beginning started off amazing and then I was even more blown away by the execution! The staff was super friendly and professional... and OMG the food! It was not only so delicious but creative and completely inspired by our preferences. KD Event Group was so easy to work with and I couldn't be happier with the service and deliciousness they provided! I would highly recommend them for any event.
Alyssa, 4 years ago
Acquolina Catering & Event Management 

5.0

  • Serves Manhattan, NY

We approach each wedding with the special attention it deserves. We’ll work with you every step of the way, bringing with us our innate sense of sophistication and elegance. With fundamentals in traditional Italian cooking, we customize every menu for each occasion and ensure that you receive the finest in Italian hospitality. We’re deeply committed to making your wedding unforgettable with fabulous food and impeccable service.

As an event planner, there is nothing better than to collaborate and work alongside a vendor like Acquolina, that you can trust to deliver the very best in quality and service time and time again. I have had the pleasure of working with Acquolina on a variety of events, both large and intricate, intimate and unique. What stands out every time is their exceptional service, and eagerness to please each and every client. No detail goes unnoticed, and every nuance of service is accounted for; from the initial planning process, through on-site execution. My clients and I are consistently thrilled with their high caliber, extremely customizable, and inventive approach to catering. The quality and presentation of their food and beverage is exceptional. They take a very personalized approach to the events they create, and I couldn’t recommend them more!
Alexandra Maione, 5 years ago
Quick responder
Platinum Party 

5.0

  • Serves Manhattan, NY

Platinum Party Planners is a full-service catering and event planning company. Our events are completely customized, we guide our clients through the planning process of selecting and designing a menu to reflect our clients’ vision. In addition, we can help you plan and design your event by selecting your event color palette, centerpieces, décor pieces etcetera. We will also coordinate with the best preferred/recommended vendors for all necessary rentals like tents, table, and chair styles and much more!! We will get every detail right on your most important day! We're with you every step of the way to ensure a flawless event.

Thanks to Tracy & George and their staffing team, our wedding day was far beyond what we ever dreamt of!!!! I will rewind back to when I first emailed Tracy about our wedding catering inquiry. She was super responsive and able to get us in for a tasting ASAP. We instantly were drawn to Platinum Party Planners because they offered a variety of catering packages and we were able to pick one that suited our budget. A lot of other caterers were firm with their pricing which is stressful! During the food tasting, Tracy sat with us to discuss our wedding day vision and took thorough notes while George cooked & served us the food. Because I did not have a "day of" planner to setup all my DIYs/decor, she said not to worry and her team would handle it (ummm AMAZING!!!!!!). At the tasting, we were blown away not only by the taste of everything, but the gorgeous plating! Everything was absolutely beautiful and screamed high end, even with our limited budget. We had our wedding at RGNY Riverhead and initially they wanted us to choose a caterer from their exclusive list. Tracy went out of her way to meet with the managers/staff at RGNY and thanks to her high level of professionalism and expertise, they allowed us to proceed with using Platinum at our caterer!!! Prior to the wedding, Platinum assembled a whole timeline/order of events for our wedding day (with my approval of course!). Fast forward to our wedding day, Tracy NAILED our decor instructions, food was delicious, and the staff was awesome!! Platinum also made up menu cards for each seat, UNREAL!! Tracy only approached me ONE time the whole wedding day and it was only to say hi and congratulations!! This showed me she had everything under control and didn't need my input on anything. Once the reception ended, the team thoroughly cleaned up and took care of disposing all the garbage. All this to say, I truly could not thank Platinum Party Planners enough. Tracy & George went above and BEYOND to make me the happiest and most stress-free bride in the world. I will forever look back on that day as the happiest day of my life. Love you guys, you are absolute PROS!!!!
Lauren C., 6 days ago
Quick responder
EVENTFULLNYC 

5.0

  • Serves Manhattan, NY

EVENTFULLNYC is a full-service, off-premise New York City Caterer working with clients in Manhattan, Brooklyn, and the tri-state area. We specialize in weddings, corporate events, galas, holiday parties, Bar/Bat Mitzvahs, and those special personal events in your home. Our Mission is to exercise flexibility, trust and detailed attention when meeting clients needs as we provide premier food, using only the finest ingredients, serviced by unobtrusive, friendly, and professional people making for a truly memorable event.

Awarded Best of Zola
Working with EVENTFULLNYC for our wedding catering was a wonderful experience. Melody and her team were warm, friendly, organized, professional, and deeply engaged throughout the entire planning process. Their communication was exceptional - they were always quick to respond, attentive to the needs of the couple, and helped ensure every detail was in place. The quality of their work was outstanding, from the delicious and beautifully presented food to the polite and friendly service. They seamlessly accommodated all of our guests' dietary restrictions and bar preferences, allowing us to fully enjoy our special day without a single hitch. EVENTFULLNYC's calm and professional demeanor added a wonderful sense of peacefulness to the celebration. We have worked with Melody and her team in the past, and they have never disappointed - they are truly a joy to collaborate with.
Lauren, 6 days ago
Quick responder
The Culinary Curate 

5.0

  • Starts at $5,000
  • Serves Manhattan, NY

With over 10 years of experience catering to various events such as political fundraisers, corporate and media events, weddings, small in-home events, movies, and even the occasional backyard barbecue, we know that the discriminating consumer is looking for one thing; great, quality service at a great value. We at The Culinary Curate aim to deliver just that. Exceptional quality, attention to YOUR finest detail for your event, world-class service, and great value are what we deliver to every client. Contact us today for a quote on your next event.

Awarded Best of Zola
We booked the Culinary Curate for an intimate buffet style wedding celebration this summer. No rainy weather could have ruined the experience. Charmaine and her team made sure every guest had a wonderful time. From the early planning days of timely communication to clean up time following the event, Charmaine and her team’s execution was exemplary. Aside from delicious food, we were treated like family. Charmaine was assertive and professional when she needed to be as well as creative and accommodating at the time of the event. Thanks for such a memorable evening!
Mariya, 3 months ago
GemHidden gem
Tavola Charcuterie 

4.7

  • Starts at $480
  • Serves Manhattan, NY

We love creating luxury charcuterie platters that allow you to gather your friends and families, enjoy the food and create unforgettable memories. We hand select every item that goes into your custom board and take so much pride in our curations. We believe in using only the freshest and finest, local ingredients. We specialize in customized charcuterie platters, corporate orders, grazing tables, and classes. Rest assured we are licensed and insured.

Tavola has now become a staple at all of our gatherings after initially featuring them at our wedding. Their charcuterie and cheese trays are beyond delicious. The ingredients are fresh and top of the line. And let’s not mention the stunning presentation. Every time I order one for an event, everyone wants to know where I got such an amazing spread from. They are the best in the business. You won’t be disappointed and your guests will rave.
Johanna M., 5 months ago
Quick responder
Fig & Pig Catering 

5.0

  • Starts at $170
  • Serves Manhattan, NY

Fig & Pig continues to be a creative, quality-driven catering company devoted to showcasing seasonal ingredients and producing exceptional, food-focused events. Our team of professionally-trained chefs cook with dedication and pride to create thoughtful meals that are both comforting and modern. We work closely with our clients to build curated menus and distinctive settings that reflect the personality and vision of their event. At Fig & Pig, the service is as important as the food. Our front of house team drives the success of each event and they take very seriously, the needs of our guests.

I have nothing but effusive praise for Fig & Pig! They were the best catering team imaginable for our fall wedding in the Catskills. Holly prepares truly delicious meals, with huge crowd pleasers including the heritage smoked chicken, lasagne, and the cocktail hour crab cakes. Throughout the planning process Tammy was always quick to respond, and eager to incorporate unique little twists. We had homemade cookies we wanted to serve alongside Fig & Pig's delightful sticky toffee pudding and strawberry shortcake -- and they ensured it happened seamlessly. The bartenders and waitstaff brought fantastic, upbeat energy to the party. I can't overstate how thoughtful Holly and Tammy were every step of the way. Just one example: Fig & Pig had a small tray of appetizers set out for us in a private area following the ceremony, so my husband and I could savor a brief moment alone and enjoy all of the canapes before joining our guests at cocktail hour. Fig & Pig's food is magnificent. The specialty cocktails are stunners. I would recommend this team to anyone -- they are absolutely stellar.
Annie, 3 months ago
Quick responder
Purslane 

5.0

  • Serves Manhattan, NY

Purslane is part of The Oberon Group, a Brooklyn neighborhood-focused restaurant group with a commitment to sustainability. We started Purslane in 2012 as a way to serve our community outside of our restaurants. Sustainability wasn’t part of our origin story, but we realized we had an opportunity to make a difference in one of the most wasteful industries out there. We are seasoned experts in executing corporate events of all sizes, ranging from galas and banquets, to private dinners, to multi-day conferences for hundreds of guests, to weekly lunch drop-offs for your whole office.

Awarded Best of Zola
We love working with Purslane at our venue! They are extremly kind, detail oriented and communicative. Both the food and service that they offer is exceptional. Partnering with vendors who are committed to sustainability and sourcing is really important to us, which is one of the many reasons we appreciate working with Purslane. They are truly helping to pave the way with their zero waste initiatives! We know that everything is going to run smoothly when Purslane's involved.
Michele Kaufman, 5 years ago
Quick responder
Krisp Events 

5.0

  • Starts at $4,000
  • Serves Manhattan, NY

Krisp Events is one of the top catering companies in New York. We bring to your party the best New York has to offer, using the finest seasonal and organic ingredients available. We pride ourselves on our international and eclectic menu and encourage suggestions for any customized menu requests. We pay very special attention to each event, and will gladly guide you through any planning to achieve the best possible experience for you and your guests. We look forward to providing you with a unique culinary event of excellence. Innovation combined with a strong work ethic is what makes Krisp who we are today.

Awarded Best of Zola
As a wedding planner many times I am managing vendors not only to confirm service but to prevent jeopardizing my clients event. Most of the time this can be frustrating especially when things are forgotten, coupled with many last minute changes, but not with Krisp Events. With Nora and Krisp Events I can close my eyes. It is important to be able to trust your vendors (especially Catering) without micromanaging. Their food is delicious, their staff is friendly, formal, and knowledgeable, and the administrative experience is seamless. Every event with Krisp, is a successful event.
Dana Butler Productions, 3 years ago
Quick responder
ITALIANA FOODS LLC 

5.0

  • Starts at $3,000
  • Serves Manhattan, NY
  • Offer

Bring the taste of Italy to your wedding celebration with ITALIANA FOODS LLC, a New Rochelle, NY-based catering company specializing in handmade Italian dishes made with love. Founders Giusy and Lucia are the sixth generation of talented culinary creatives in their family. They are honored to share the incredible food traditions of their Italian hometown with couples and their loved ones throughout the Westchester area. In addition to their catering services, Italiana foods also offer a beautiful and Romantic Vintage APE Piaggio 1976 build Food Truck that adds a little fun and excitement to any occasion.

Italiana Foods LLC exceeded our expectations as the caterers for our wedding. On the day of the wedding, their team was professional, efficient, and attentive to all of our guests' needs. Our guests raved about the food from appetizers to main course to desserts. Italiana Foods' attention to detail and commitment to delivering an exceptional dining experience made them an integral part of making our wedding day so special. We highly recommend them to any couple looking for an authentic Italian catering option.
Kayla W., a month ago
Quick responder
Club Feast 

4.7

  • Starts at $1
  • Serves Manhattan, NY

Planning a wedding? Let Club Feast take the stress out of your catering needs! We offer tailored catering solutions that save you time and money, all while supporting local, minority-owned restaurants. Whether you're organizing a small gathering or a grand celebration, we’ll work with you to create the perfect menu for your special day. Let’s chat about how we can make your wedding meal unforgettable – without the hassle!

The Club Feast team was a pleasure to work with for our Workplace catering. Their communication was concise, attentive, professional, and friendly throughout the planning process. The quality of their work and value provided was satisfying, prompt, helpful, and professional. The Club Feast team was able to support our needs, from small office lunches to our large-scale workplace events, creating a wonderful experience for the team onsite. We were very pleased with the service and support they provided to make our experience as premium as possible.
Daliza G., 25 days ago
TrendlineTrending
Dish Food & Events 

5.0

  • Starts at $150 per person
  • Serves Manhattan, NY

Dish Food & Events is an award-winning, full-service catering and events company serving all of New York City and The Hamptons for over 15 years. Recognized for our warm hospitality and delicious food, Dish creates remarkable weddings, social gatherings, and corporate events. What truly differentiates Dish is our diverse team. We are committed to creating an awesome place to work while taking great care of each other, our partners and our guests.

Working with Evalyn, Cortney, and the team at Dish was a truly incomparable experience! I had the pleasure of getting to know Dish a few years back at my first job and had told my contact at the time, Bonnie, that I would definitely be back when it was time for me to host my big event - my wedding. After reconnecting with the Dish team, in particular speaking with Evalyn, we couldn't have felt more confident that it was the right fit for our big day. From the personalized menu, to the in house tasting, and the amazing day of coordinator, Cortney, the most important and expensive party we ever threw (and likely ever will) was in the best hands. When any changes or adjustments came up the team was eager to help make our vision come to life. A few weeks before when I wanted to do another itinerary run through, Cortney, was not just game, but so enthusiastic and supportive. As small things came up day of, Evalyn and Cortney were on it and as we were packing up, the whole Dish team helped us pack up and carry out our numerous flower arrangements. We truly couldn't have pulled this off without Dish and are so grateful for their partnership. Thank you, Dish!
Sarah C., 19 days ago
TrendlineTrending
Sips on the Hudson Mobile Bar and Mini Pancakes 

5.0

  • Starts at $700
  • Serves Manhattan, NY

We are based in Hudson Valley and serve Orange, Dutchess, Putnam, Westchester, Rockland, NJ, PA and CT. Our Mobile Bar offers the full bartending experience while serving our delicious made-to-order mini pancakes. Bartenders are TIPS certified, and we use local ingredients for our hand-crafted cocktails. Services can be combined or separated upon request.

Sips on the Hudson were outstanding. I hired them for my duaghters bridal shower. It was easy. From making the reservation, to setting up the truck. It was all so simple, professional and clean. It was a hit. My guests loved it. The pancakes are delicious. They offer a variety of toppings and everything is fresh. The custom drinks were to die for. I highly recommend them. I will definately be using them again for any future event. Hopefully a baby shower.
Susan, 5 months ago
TrendlineTrending
Green Cart Catering 

5.0

  • Starts at $52
  • Serves Manhattan, NY

Green Cart Catering was founded on the desire to do two things: One, to provide healthy & ethical cuisine. And two, to provide event hosts, committed to healthy & ethical eating, the ability to stay true to their values while still providing their guests an outstanding culinary experience! Our 100% plant- based menus will impress everyone and leave no one wanting! Behind our great food is over 30 years’ experience in hospitality services. So, Green Cart Catering can provide you with not only great food, but complete event services, as well!

As a vendor of rental equipment, we've watched Green Cart Catering grow from the early days of the pandemic and mature into a well-managed off-premise caterer. From our vantage point we know the company is well-managed, organized, and committed to delivering great service.
David VanDenburgh, 19 days ago
Quick responder
Delivering EXperiences LLC 

5.0

  • Starts at $2,000
  • Serves Manhattan, NY

We are committed to making each event a unique experience, based on creativity, innovation, and the ideas of our clients we will design memorable events with a carefully crafted menu. Our goal is to exceed our clients expectations and impress their guests. Inspiration, innovation, exquisite presentation are our ket tenants. With more than 24 years of planning and executing memorable events, we will make sure your event stands out from the rest.

We hired Juan and his team for our small wedding and we have to say that the experience was absolutely phenomenal from start to finish, Juan was very attentive and envisioned what we wanted for our day, the proposal was very transparent and fair enough, they went above and beyond our expectations, the menu was a very unique and creative great combination of flavor and colors, service was top notch. I will definitively continue working with this company which provides very personalized service and takes really good care of all the details
David & T., 4 years ago

Location flexible? Discover caterers near Manhattan, NY

About wedding caterers in Manhattan, NY

How much do catering services usually cost in Manhattan, NY?

Full service catering packages range from $100 to $18,000 and average around $1,500.

Which are the most popular caterers in Manhattan, NY?

Some of the most popular caterers in this area include Infuse Catering & Events, Insatiable Eats Catering and JPO Concepts | Catering.

Do catering packages include serving staff?

Yes! 40% of packages in Manhattan, NY include serving staff, such as servers and bussers. Many others also include rental coordination, just ask before you book!

Can caterers in Manhattan, NY accommodate specialized diets?

They can! 18 offer kosher services and 64 offer vegetarian packages. You can search on Zola for caterers who can accommodate nut-free, dairy-free, gluten-free, halal and vegan diets as well!

What types of caterers are in Manhattan, NY?

What other Manhattan vendors will I need?

What other caterers are nearby?

What other wedding services are nearby?