The Best Seafood Wedding Catering in Old Tappan, NJ

The Best Seafood Wedding Catering in Old Tappan, NJ

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


24 Wedding Caterers in Old Tappan, NJ

Seafood
Clear
Quick responder
MAHFY Catering 

5.0

  • Starts at $2,500
  • Serves Old Tappan, NJ

We are MAHFY Catering and we're dedicated to delivering one-of-a-kind experiences for your special celebration. Our talented chefs are passionate about serving our delicious fusion of world-famous flavors that will have your guests asking for seconds. With a focus on using high quality ingredients, tried-and-proven recipes and elegant presentations, MAHFY Catering aims to exceed your expectations from start to finish.

Awarded Best of Zola
Aiyana and Keith were amazing from being to end. I hired them as the caterers for my wedding (100ppl). Their communication was timely and professional. This is one of the reasons we chose MAHFY over other catering vendors. We were able to do a tasting, which we made it into a whole date night. It was really good. We love their food and they have such positive energy. They helped us customize our menu. All requirements on their end were met for our venue. Last minute (two weeks prior) I needed extra help with clean up and they agreed to get more staff. My event decorator raved about how helpful they were with setup. They were early and ready to go! The cocktail hour and reception food was good and we received a lot of compliments from our guest. We also hired them to bartend the wedding and drinks were great as well. Clean up was fast and to the point. All staff were helpful, kind and professional. I cannot thank MAHFY for catering my wedding and making it a memorable night for us and our guest.
Alyna, 4 months ago
Quick responder
Renegade Outpost 

5.0

  • Starts at $1,500
  • Serves Old Tappan, NJ
  • Offer

Renegade Outpost is a full service event planning and chef services company. We've been in business for 7 years and have been working with Thumbtack. We have been hired more than 400 times and have 190 5-star reviews. We offer logistical services as well as day/of coordination and securing rentals. Our "rolodex" includes many of the best vendors for all your event needs. Making your job easier is our highest priority. Wonderful food always begins with amazing ingredients, especially produce. We source directly from local farmers, we work with an organic butcher, a wild fish monger and importers of select cheese and specialty products.

Awarded Best of Zola
Working with Ellen was wonderful. Her professionalism, courtesy and thoughtfulness were outstanding. Her food was both delicious and presented beautifully. I am so happy I went with her and will gladly call her again. So low key and genuinely a very nice person. She helped with so many things that were above and beyond her job. I highly recommend Ellen to cater your party. Mine was a graduation party at a community room in a NYC apartment building. It has difficult parking and drop off for all her catering materials. But Ellen made it work. She also helped me plan a very tasteful menu. Also her assistant, Alex, was so professional and diligent. They both really helped make my party a success!"
Patty V., 3 years ago
Quick responder
Purslane 

5.0

  • Serves Old Tappan, NJ

Purslane is part of The Oberon Group, a Brooklyn neighborhood-focused restaurant group with a commitment to sustainability. We started Purslane in 2012 as a way to serve our community outside of our restaurants. Sustainability wasn’t part of our origin story, but we realized we had an opportunity to make a difference in one of the most wasteful industries out there. We are seasoned experts in executing corporate events of all sizes, ranging from galas and banquets, to private dinners, to multi-day conferences for hundreds of guests, to weekly lunch drop-offs for your whole office.

Awarded Best of Zola
We love working with Purslane at our venue! They are extremly kind, detail oriented and communicative. Both the food and service that they offer is exceptional. Partnering with vendors who are committed to sustainability and sourcing is really important to us, which is one of the many reasons we appreciate working with Purslane. They are truly helping to pave the way with their zero waste initiatives! We know that everything is going to run smoothly when Purslane's involved.
Michele Kaufman, 5 years ago
Quick responder
La Mila Catering & Events 

5.0

  • Starts at $75
  • Serves Old Tappan, NJ

Starting their careers in the restaurant and food industry, Elie & Heidi Hanna decided to utilize their unique experiences and create their own vision of a full service event company. La Mila is named after their daughter, Milana, who provides them with limitless inspiration and motivation.

Awarded Best of Zola
As a classically trained chef, I hope my review of La Mila inspires anyone doing their “homework” to earn an A — for themselves, especially their guests. I’ve been to many weddings, and the food served is often an edible afterthought. How many times, when leaving a wedding, were you asked, “What did you think about the food?” — and you replied with shrugged shoulders, “Eh, it was okay.” That is not the case with La Mila. A huge shoutout and thank you to Sandy, who was able to pull together a phenomenal menu all in a very timely timeline. Sandy was honest, upfront, and available around our busy work schedule. The day before and the day of, Sandy was there to help with setup — from the big asks, like helping move furniture, to the small tasks—like lighting lanterns and ensuring no glass of champagne for our toast was served empty! Given our wedding took place at our home, we thoroughly appreciated Sandy staying late to clean the kitchen, empty overflowing garbage, and make sure our home was not a war zone when we woke up the next morning! Elie’s execution of our menu was stellar. As a classically trained chef, I was thoroughly impressed by the well-run machine Elie could create within our garage, the makeshift kitchen for the event. It rained on our wedding day, and we were blessed with a beautiful, vivid rainbow—right before dinner service. This blessing brought all our guests outside for 30 minutes—right before dinner. A major wrench in the moment-by-moment timeline. I know how this, for many chefs, can be a disruptive, unexpected delay—but Elie did not miss a beat. All of our guests raved about the food—notably friends who I graduated with from the Culinary Institute of America. One thing I learned in culinary school is that you “eat with your eyes first.” Simply put, Heidi’s presentation skills are on point! Her attention to detail in creating beautiful food displays, notably for our cocktail hour, showed the care, thought and love we wanted our guests to feel. Sandy, Elie, and Heidi may be the stars of La Mila’s show—but the success of our wedding would not have been possible without their hard-working and friendly staff. One of the elements that sold us on choosing La Mila, was their well-stocked arsenal of kitchen equipment they brought on site. (Most caterers require you rent equipment separately, which is not only more expensive, but introduces a whole new dimension of moving parts.) La Mila was also able to include chinaware, silverware, and the majority of our glassware! They even included soft drinks, water, condiments, cocktail napkins, etc. — all of this, and they still came in under what we were quoted by other caterers. Thank you, Sandy, Elie, Heidi, and the entire La Mila Catering & Events team, for making our wedding day what it was. Your talent, professionalism, and experience were felt by everyone who took part in our special day.
Jordan R. S., 4 months ago
Quick responder
BISSOU 

4.0

  • Starts at $4,500
  • Serves Old Tappan, NJ

Our innovative presentation will redefine your perception of indulgence, combining sumptuous amenities and top tier dining options to create an impeccable experience tailored to your personal taste. Our culinary acumen with proficiency in contemporary cooking and commitment to sourcing the highest quality ingredient. With the service ranging from meal prep for individual and daily need, personal chef services for your intimate dinner, to gastronomic delight up to silver spoon class matrimonial soirees. Our team is well verse in every aspect of the event and will undoubtedly delivery top notch services.

We had our wedding ceremony during Covid and we didn’t want to do the courthouse so we had a small ceremony at home with brunch catered by Bissou it was a great experience and my guest were happy with all the food choices especially with the omelette bar I would definitely book again.
Suprena, 10 months ago
Quick responder
Simply Delicious Dishes 

5.0

  • Starts at $3,000
  • Serves Old Tappan, NJ

We are a full service catering team that specializes in southern cuisine with a stylish flare! It is our passion and decorative attention to detail that has carried us for many years. We love what we do, and we will cater any event large or small with that same passion and service attention. We build strong lasting relationships with our clients, and take great pride in serving others. We also offer all inclusive services that cater to all your event preparations and needs. We take care of everything so that you don't have to!

Simply Delicious Dishes was an absolute pleasure to work with for our wedding catering. From the first time we reached out, they were incredibly kind, helpful, and patient in answering all of our questions. Their communication was consistently informative, ensuring we felt well taken care of throughout the entire planning process. On the day of the wedding, their team's excellent work, punctuality, and attention to detail were evident in the exceptional quality of the food and service they provided. I would greatly recommend Simply Delicious Dishes to any couple - they are simply the best wedding caterers we could have hoped for.
Danille and S., a month ago
Quick responder
Michael's Event Catering 

5.0

  • Starts at $3,500
  • Serves Old Tappan, NJ

We are an off-premise, full service caterer, who specializes in custom weddings, with experienced and friendly service staff, along with food truck services. We strive to make your special day as stress free as possible by taking all the guess work out of rentals, set-up, food, staffing, etc. We will meet with you, help build a timeline for your event, take care of all your rental needs and execute with profession for a successful event! With our catering company, we bring the kitchen to you!

Michael's Event Catering was an excellent choice for our wedding catering. They were very communicative throughout the planning process, answering all of our questions promptly and working closely with us to ensure our vision was executed perfectly. On the day of, their staff provided top-notch service, making sure all of our guests were well taken care of and that we had everything we needed. The food was absolutely delicious - fresh, high-quality ingredients prepared with care. Their employees were all professional and courteous, dressed in uniforms that gave the event a polished, elegant feel. We were thrilled with the value we received and would highly recommend Michael's Event Catering to any couple planning their wedding.
Shannon H., a month ago
Quick responder
Shore Catering 

5.0

  • Serves Old Tappan, NJ

5-Star Full-Service Catering from casual to elegant for all occasions since 1988. We offer packages for all occasions such as wedding receptions, lobster clambakes, bbq picnics, beach parties, showers, anniversaries, and so much more. Our team will assist you from start to finish, planning your menu, coordinating rentals, linen colors, floorplans, timelines, vendor referrals, private tastings and so much more. We bring our catering services to all corners of New Jersey and will also assist you in trying to find the perfect venue to suit your event's needs. Shore Catering can help make your event a memorable occasion.

When we tasted the food we knew that our guests would be happy with our selection of shore catering (and we were right! We recieved many compliments on the dinner and hors d'oeuvres). What we DIDN'T realize is that we were receiving more than just a catering service- we were receiving what felt like a warm welcome into a family business that took some of the stress out of the wedding planning process! Shore was the only caterer we encountered that was willing to work within our budget, and individually tailor a package to meet our needs, allowing us to feel comfortable financially without feeling like we were sacrificing ANY of the quality and elegance that we wanted for our wedding! Moreover, on the day of our wedding, summer took care of us as though we were her oldest friends, meeting us with so much genuine warmth and a contagious smile. She made sure we were able to actually eat and drink (which so many of our friends told us would be difficult to do at our wedding!) and kept the vibe HIGH even in spite of pouring rain and floods on the day of the event! We wish we could get married again and again and we would hire Shore Catering every single time!! I HIGHLY recommend Shore Catering to any bride and groom who want all of the quality with none of the stress!
Laura & M., a year ago
Quick responder
Late to the Lake 

5.0

  • Starts at $450
  • Serves Old Tappan, NJ for additional fees

Great taste is the name of the game and we're committed to stepping up to the plate. Our goal is provide unforgettable, delicious, and eye catching options. That's why we prepare all of our boards and graze displays to your style, with the highest quality products. Whether it is an intimate dinner or an event for up to 800 guests, we do it all! If you are considering a Graze table for your wedding or next event, reach out and we'd be delighted to create something beautiful for you!

Awarded Best of Zola
Late to the Lake was the perfect wedding caterer for our special day. From the very beginning, their communication was on top of it wonderful - they were incredibly responsive and attentive to all of our questions and requests. The quality of their work and value was simply delicious, unforgettable, and outstanding. They went above and beyond in so many ways, even helping with extra services we didn't even expect. Late to the Lake was a crucial part of the success of our wedding, and we appreciated Danae, Carly, and Ryanne's kindness and impeccable service throughout the entire process. We couldn't have asked for a better catering team to make our wedding day truly unforgettable.
Maggie & E., 4 months ago
TrendlineTrending
Industry Standard Events 

5.0

  • Starts at $5,000
  • Serves Old Tappan, NJ for additional fees
  • Offer

Industry Standard Events (ISE) is a premier event planning and catering service founded in 2000 by Executive Chef Jason Tell and recently partnered with Derek Nickerson, Tech Entrepreneur. With a deep-rooted friendship spanning over 12 years and a combined 30 years of experience in the industry, Derek and Jason are dedicated to creating unforgettable, bespoke events. Our mission is to bring people together through exceptional culinary experiences and meticulous event planning, ensuring every occasion is unique and memorable. At ISE, we believe in the power of personalized service and attention to detail, making each event a true masterpiece.

Awarded Best of Zola
We got so many compliments on the food from our wedding guests! I will recommend this business again and again. So easy to work with and professional as well.
Alissa H., 8 months ago
Quick responder
Events and Weddings By Allan 

5.0

  • Starts at $3,000
  • Serves Old Tappan, NJ for additional fees

Welcome to Events and Weddings By Allan! Our family owned restaurant is a celebration of the Mediterranean region known for its fresh ingredients, bold flavors, and healthy dishes. Our Chef Allan Abbad uses authentic recipes and techniques that have been passed down through generations. Whether you are enjoying our signature hummus, falafel, or kebabs, you can be sure that you are eating the real thing. In addition to our exceptional cuisine, we offer planning services that are tailored to your needs and preferences. From menu planning to decor and party favors, we take care of everything so that you can sit back and enjoy the festivities.

Awarded Best of Zola
From the moment we sat down to discuss our wedding with Allan and Tatiana, we felt as though we were with family. They listened attentively to what we wanted regarding the food, and assured us that they would accommodate our wishes. After we had a tasting of various salads, appetizers and main courses, we knew that we had found exactly what we were looking for. We chose a Mediterranian style menu, and we felt that their food was the best we had ever tasted Our wedding was held in the Catskills in a rustic barn setting. Allan came and set up an entire kitchen that rivaled any catering facilty. Our guests were met at the cocktail hour by a courteous, kind wait staff and a presentation of beautiful, colorful dishes that were plentiful and delicious! The celebration meal was complete with a choices of main dishes that pleased every palate. The wedding is now behind us, but our family and friends still rave about the delicious food that was served on that day. Allan always said that he wanted our day to be perfect, and it was! You can not find more sincere caring people than Allan, Tatiana and their staff. They helped to make our wedding "outstanding in every way."
Mara L., a month ago
Quick responder
Haute Feast 

5.0

  • Starts at $5,000
  • Serves Old Tappan, NJ for additional fees

As luxury wedding and events caterers based in New Jersey, we are committed to creating unparalleled experiences packed with mouth-watering flavors, a sense of magic, and meticulous attention to detail. Our food is approachable, yet elegant, and made with love, fresh, on-site with excellent technique. Since it’s our belief that great meals begin with exceptional ingredients, we take our cues from our trusted local farmers, fishermen & artisan purveyors. We source the freshest, seasonal, high-quality ingredients when preparing menus for your events, whether we’re cooking for 10 or for 100.

Awarded Best of Zola
From another vendors prospective Carey and the Haute Feast team are a dream to work with. The food from start to finish is always on point. Carey is incredibly friendly and 100% professional as is her entire team. The food is devine and their presentation is too! Their clients rave about the food, drinks and service. I am always excited when I know they are part of the team as they bring their game every time!
Flowers From the Farm NJ, 3 years ago
TrendlineTrending
Pheasant 

5.0

  • Serves Old Tappan, NJ

We LOVE weddings here at Pheasant! Being entrusted with one of the most important days of a couple’s life is not something we take lightly. After all, the bridal couple may be the focus of the day, but an amazing meal and impeccable service will make the entire event that much more memorable. Our knowledgeable staff will help guide you through the decision-making process as we go through menus, table scapes, furniture, timing, bar service and more together. We also have a strong rolodex of planners and florists that we work with on a regular basis - just ask us for more info!

Our company has been working with Pheasant for several years now, they are on our very small list of preferred catering partners that we recommend to our clients. Not only is their food incredibly delicious (every time) but working with Cat and Lola and the rest of the Pheasant team is truly a joy! You are always in the best hands with Pheasant!
Michele, 2 years ago

Location flexible? Discover caterers near Old Tappan, NJ

About wedding caterers in Old Tappan, NJ

How much do catering services usually cost in Old Tappan, NJ?

Full service catering packages range from $150 to $18,000 and average around $1,000.

Which are the most popular caterers in Old Tappan, NJ?

Some of the most popular caterers in this area include JPO Concepts | Catering, Krisp Events and EVENTfull.NYC.

Do catering packages include serving staff?

Yes! 45% of packages in Old Tappan, NJ include serving staff, such as servers and bussers. Many others also include rental coordination, just ask before you book!

Can caterers in Old Tappan, NJ accommodate specialized diets?

They can! 19 offer kosher services and 54 offer vegetarian packages. You can search on Zola for caterers who can accommodate nut-free, dairy-free, gluten-free, halal and vegan diets as well!

What types of caterers are in Old Tappan, NJ?

What other Old Tappan vendors will I need?

What other caterers are nearby?

What other wedding services are nearby?