The Best Sugar-Free Wedding Cake Bakeries in Star Lake, NY

The Best Sugar-Free Wedding Cake Bakeries in Star Lake, NY

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?

6 Wedding Cakes & Desserts in Star Lake, NY

Sugar-free
Quick responder
Chai Chief 

5.0

  • Starts at $100
  • Serves Star Lake, NY
  • Offer

We create moments never forgotten. The spirit of being together must be celebrated, the joy and authenticity of creating experiences for the most magical people in your life is what drives our mission.

“This was an incredibly unique experience. No other vendor has the service or offering that chai Chief have for a wedding so they aren’t even comparable as they are so unique. I was able to choose from over 25 flavors that were so delicious and immaculately presented. Chai Chief team are professional and work their heart out for that “ moment” .”
Sarah, 6 months ago
TrendlineTrending
Friday Harvest Bakery 

5.0

  • Starts at $4
  • Serves Star Lake, NY for additional fees

Hey there! My name is Claire, and I'm a small-scale baker focused on bringing the flavors and aesthetics that every couple wants for the best part of every wedding - the dessert! You can count on me to use as many whole, fresh, and local ingredients as possible, while working with you and your tastes to build an amazing dessert selection.

“Claire made planning our dessert menu an absolute breeze. I wanted simple, minimal, and delicious for a dessert bar and she nailed it. She was wonderful about accommodating a quick tasting while we were travelling from out of state, and made sure to keep us in the loop on all updates. We had honey almond, spice cake, salted caramel, and vegan/GF chocolate cupcakes that were devoured by guests - we were lucky there were a couple left for us to save for ourselves! Claire also lent us some rustic display pieces that just brought everything together flawlessly with our rainy fall day, I could not have asked for better. We are already talking about placing orders on our anniversaries in the future! Thank you for everything Claire3”
Madison C., a year ago
Sugar, Spice and Nice Things 

5.0

  • Starts at $120
  • Serves Star Lake, NY for additional fees

Sugar, Spice and Nice Things is a small bakeshop located in Hewlett, NY, on the South Shore of Nassau County, proudly serving customers on Long Island, NYC and beyond. We believe wholeheartedly in quality over quantity, so though we be but small, we are mighty! Our intention is to bake as fresh as possible with our quality ingredients for you to enjoy as soon as possible. At Sugar, Spice and Nice Things, we are constantly inspired by nature and appreciate life's great pleasures in the nice simple things. Long Island Choice Awards 2025

“Sugar, Spice and Nice Things was an absolute delight to work with for our wedding desserts! They were incredibly responsive and paid close attention to every detail, ensuring our order was perfect. Each piece they handcrafted was exquisitely made and absolutely delicious - my serotonin loved them! The quality and value of their work was top-notch, and we couldn't have been happier. Very professional, tasteful, and you truly can't go wrong with Sugar, Spice and Nice Things for your wedding. Highly recommend!”
Samantha, 3 months ago
TrendlineTrending
Lucifly Cakes 

5.0

  • Starts at $800
  • Serves Star Lake, NY

Creating a high-quality, stunning cake is what motivates me in the kitchen. Of course, a cake should taste just as delicious as it looks! I hope for the design of my cakes to inspire joy and wonder, and the eating of them to make people smile. Nothing makes me happier than delivering clients their dream cake!

Awarded Best of Zola
“Everything worked out great with this cake, and we couldn’t have been happier. It was a beautiful cake and everything was smooth with the transportation, set up,, decoration, and of course the taste! It had one gluten-free tier that was as good as the rest. Guests were very happy with cake and none was left!”
Derrick B., 5 years ago
Shae's Cakes 

5.0

  • Starts at $1
  • Serves Star Lake, NY

Hello! My name is Shaelyn Oathout. I am the self taught one woman show behind Shae’s Cakes, an in-home bakery based in Poland, NY. I’m so glad you’re here! Shae’s Cakes started early in 2020 as a hobby, but I quickly realized just how passionate I am about starting from scratch, and bringing people’s sweet dreams to life! I look forward to getting to know you, and helping you create tasty memories that will last a lifetime!

“Shae’s Cakes made cake pops for our wedding. She made 4 different unique flavors, and they were the most delicious cake pops I’ve ever had! People still talk about them over a year later! It makes a huge difference knowing that the dessert served at my wedding was rememberable. We will be using Shae’s Cakes for all of our events in the future! She is very easy to work with and accommodating.”
Andres & B., 3 years ago
Cakes by Iliyana 
  • Starts at $1,200
  • Serves Star Lake, NY

Cakes by Iliyana creates luxurious boutique level cakes that we like to refer to as modern cake art! We have won several awards for our wedding cake creations and we pride ourselves on providing our clients with an exclusive design and an attentive experience. By pairing unique and delicious flavors with a whimsical design, our cakes will add an additional layer of joy and happiness to your event! We are located in the capital region of New York and we can not wait to create an edible piece of art that will become an incredible element of your special day!

Location flexible? Discover cakes & desserts near Star Lake, NY

Quick responder
Renaissance Pastry

5.0 (4)

Brattleboro, VT
TrendlineTrending
Sweet Buckets

5.0 (5)

Florence, KY
BakerBitesCo

5.0 (1)

Winfield, IL
TrendlineTrending
Friday Harvest Bakery

5.0 (4)

Brandon, VT
Centerpiece Cakes By Steph

5.0 (1)

Sunderland, VT
GemHidden gem
Petrova Chocolates

5.0 (4)

Boston, MA
Sweet Vermont Treats

4.4 (7)

Barre, VT
Thistle and Honey Baking
Middlebury, VT
That Cake Stand

5.0 (6)

Burlington, VT
Quick responder
Fancy Pants Cakes

5.0 (2)

BENNINGTON, VT
GemHidden gem
The Goose Chase Cake Design

5.0 (2)

Waitsfield, VT
Cakes in Vermont
Northfield, VT

About wedding cakes & desserts in Star Lake, NY

What other Star Lake vendors will I need?

What other cakes and desserts are nearby?

What other wedding services are nearby?