The Best Wedding Cake Bakeries in New Castle, CO

The Best Wedding Cake Bakeries in New Castle, CO

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


18 Wedding Cakes & Desserts in New Castle, CO

Quick responder
Afternoon Delight Bakery 

5.0

  • Starts at $1,000
  • Serves New Castle, CO

I live in Glenwood Springs with my husband and two little boys, Jameson and Dax. We love to go Jeeping and camping whenever we can! I’ve been creating wedding cakes for over 10 years now and I strive to keep learning and getting better with every cake. I’m proud to say that I’ve recently completed my diploma in Professional Pastry Arts through Auguste Escoffier School of Culinary Arts! Its truly one of my greatest joys in life to be a small part in such big events in people’s lives.

Awarded Best of Zola
We absolutely loved working with Afternoon Delight Bakery and would recommend them to anyone! We are a couple from Iowa that got married in Colorado and she was super easy to work with and the cake was amazing. All of our guests were raving about it!
Destiny K., 2 months ago
Quick responder
Gingerly Baked 

5.0

  • Starts at $1,200
  • Serves New Castle, CO

Hi! My name is Amanda, the Chef and Owner of Gingerly Baked. My passion is creating beautiful and delicious cakes and desserts for your special occasion. I refuse to compromise quality. Everything is made from scratch, with superior ingredients, and with love.

Awarded Best of Zola
Gingerly Baked was an absolute pleasure to work with for our wedding cake. From our first interaction, they were respectful, specific, and timely in their communication, making the entire process seamless. The quality of their work was nothing short of extraordinary - the cake they delivered was not only gorgeous to look at, but also delicious beyond belief. They even took the time to personally thank and congratulate us, which was such a thoughtful touch. We were blown away by the level of detail and care they put into creating the most perfect cake I've ever seen. Gingerly Baked truly helped make our special day even more magical.
Rachel K., a month ago
TrendlineTrending
Phresh Baked Goods 

5.0

  • Starts at $150
  • Serves New Castle, CO

Phresh Baked Goods is owned and operated in Denver, Colorado by Chelsea Berman, a professionally trained pastry chef with nearly 15 years of experience. Chelsea started Phresh Baked Goods in 2020 after leaving a previous full-time pastry chef position at a local successful high-volume catering company. Chelsea enjoys bringing joy to people through food by creating highly customized, luxury edible works of art for life's best occasions.

Both of us are not typically cake people, but Chelsea knocked our wedding cake out of the park! We did a traditional two-tier wedding cake, as well as a sheet cake and not only did the cakes taste amazing, the looked absolutely wonderful as well! Chelsea's flavor selection is impeccable and if you decide to go with her you will not be dissapointed as she has flavors that cater to everyone's taste buds!
Rebecca A., 22 days ago
TrendlineTrending
Petrova Chocolates 

5.0

  • Starts at $400
  • Serves New Castle, CO

Petrova Chocolates was established in 2020 and since then we have been focusing on creating eye-catching, artisanal chocolate bonbons, truffles, chocolate bars and caramels with unique flavor combinations. Our chocolates are the perfect sweet touch to every event whether as a guest gift, a chocolate dessert table set-up or as a delicious name tag at every guest's seat. We are excited to hear from you and be given the opportunity to sweeten your special day!

Awarded Best of Zola
I tried Petrova Chocolates for the first time at a Winter market last year in Boston. I bought the Milk chocolate with crispy crepe and cinnamon and the signature Bonbon collection and can tell that the chocolates were amazing. I have been ordering since then and would definitely recommend the Strawberry and Cream bar. All of the chocolates in her selection are unique and I can tell that it is the best homemade chocolate I've ever had. Petrova Chocolates is the place to go for any event from a birthday party to a wedding. The owner, Betty is also very responsive and always makes sure that her clients are satisfied with their orders.
Before You Say I Do, a year ago
GemHidden gem
Kelly Leigh Cakes 

5.0

  • Starts at $650
  • Serves New Castle, CO

Welcome! I have been passionate about baking & cake decorating ever since I can remember. I started Kelly Leigh Cakes in 2017 & have had the pleasure of working with hundreds of lovely couples for their weddings. I attended Johnson & Wales University College of Pastry Arts in Denver and there I discovered my true love for creating specialty cakes. My work has been featured in publications such as Rocky Mountain Bride, Couture Colorado & Aisle Society. I'm a Colorado native & the mountains are my happy place. It is a privilege to do what I love & to work with couples on their special day!

Awarded Best of Zola
I knew we wanted a Kelly Leigh cake since trying one at a wedding in 2018!! We had a small cake for our elopement in 2022 and three cakes, including a GF for our reception in 2023 and couldn't be happier!! Kelly listened to my ideas, created masterpieces, and made the most delicious and beautiful cakes for our special days!! The lavender earl grey is my favorite, and my husband loved the chocolate berry!! You really can't go wrong with any of the amazing flavors!! I am a wedding photographer as well and recommend Kelly to every one of my couples. Shes the sweetest and creates the BEST cakes!
Julia G., a year ago
Quick responder
Button Rock Bakery 

5.0

  • Starts at $48
  • Serves New Castle, CO

Welcome to Button Rock Bakery! As one of the premier wedding bakeries in Colorado, we take pride in crafting wedding cakes that are as unique as your love story. Our commitment to customer service ensures that every couple feels valued and heard throughout the entire process, from initial consultation to the last bite of cake. Owned and operated by a woman entrepreneur, BRB brings a personal touch to every creation. With over 500 wedding cakes expertly crafted annually, our team combines skill, creativity, and dedication to make your wedding cake dreams come true. Let us be just a "slice" of your big day.

Button Rock Bakery was a dream to work with for our wedding cakes and desserts. Their communication throughout the process was quick, easy, and clear, making the planning seamless. The quality of their work and value was outstanding - their cakes were not only affordable, but delicious with a wide selection of flavors. The cake design they created for us was beautiful and exactly what we envisioned, and the variety of desserts they provided for our guests was amazing. We were thrilled with the service and products from Button Rock Bakery and would highly recommend them to any couple planning their wedding.
Grace D., 4 days ago
TrendlineTrending
Sweet Buckets 

5.0

  • Starts at $300
  • Serves New Castle, CO for additional fees

We began as a concession company providing cotton candy at sporting events. In the fall of 2021, we extended our brand by starting our own manufacturing plant. Sweet Buckets was born as an option for customers and businesses to purchase Cotton Candy and Gourmet popcorns direct from our company.

Awarded Best of Zola
We had our wedding reception at a brewery and wanted some easy to eat sweet and salty snacks. These popcorn flavors were delicious, they sent us flavors to try before we decided. We chose 4 flavors and they shipped them right to our house. The popcorn buckets had our cute custom labels which they designed for us and looked PERFECT! We had tons of compliments on the popcorn. We ordered plenty and people were grabbing them to take home at the end of the night. A perfect snack after a few beers. Theu were very fast with the samples and the order too!
Lyndsey C., 6 months ago

Location flexible? Discover cakes & desserts near New Castle, CO

About wedding cakes & desserts in New Castle, CO

How much do wedding cakes usually cost in New Castle, CO?

Wedding cake package prices vary.

Do bakers in New Castle, CO offer cakes for special diets?

They do! 14 offer Gluten-free desserts, and 11 offer Vegan options.1 offers Sugar-free options.

What are the most popular cake and dessert options in New Castle, CO?

The most popular wedding cake vendors in New Castle, CO are Finally Vegan Macarons, Petrova Chocolates and Sweet Buckets.

What other New Castle vendors will I need?

What other cakes and desserts are nearby?

What other wedding services are nearby?