The Best Documentary Wedding Videographers in Valley Stream, NY

The Best Documentary Wedding Videographers in Valley Stream, NY

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


27 Wedding Videographers in Valley Stream, NY

Documentary
Clear
Quick responder
ALENKA FILMS 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $3,000
  • Serves Valley Stream, NY

Hi! I'm Alëna! I’ve been making videos for over 10 years now. I believe in sucking the joy out of life and documenting the human experience authentically. Please read more ON MY WEBSITE and INQUIRE THERE OR VIA EMAIL ONLY (not zola). *So please check out my links instead. -> Almost fully BOOKED FOR 2025! I love capturing different traditions & religions AND of course documenting your love or breaking the dance floor are my literal favs! Let's freakin' go yeah!?

Awarded Best of Zola
I was on the fence about getting a videographer due to budgetary reasons and not knowing if I would really treasure it compared to photos. After several discussions with my family, I decided to book a videographer and found Alenka Films. I have to say, hiring Alenka Films to shoot our wedding was one of the best decisions we made! She went above and beyond to capture our day. From the pre-wedding discussions and check-ins, to the day-of logistics and everything after the day, Alena has been so responsive and communicative - I never had any worries about her ability to follow through and provide the best videos possible. She captured all of the most important parts of our day and even stayed a little late to get some amazing shots of our guests dancing. Since the wedding day, the videos were provided well within the given timeframes and are all so beautiful. Everyone I have shown the videos compliments them so much. I am so glad we hired Alena to film our day and that we have a beautiful video to look back on for years to come!
Madelyn S., 2 years ago
Quick responder
550Park Luxury Wedding Films 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $3,250
  • Serves Valley Stream, NY

Brent is considered one of the top wedding cinematographers based out of the Northeastern USA. He frequently travels the globe, documenting weddings for couples who deserve the best of the best. After growing up in Central Jersey, Brent chose to move down to Nashville for college and then shortly after graduation, officially founded 550Park out of New York City. He is a passionate tennis player, chef, and world adventurer.

Awarded Best of Zola
Brent's work jumped out at me before I even met him as something special, and his professionalism and experience shone through in our interactions with 550Park all the way through. He was so easy to work with and really helped put us both at ease (not the easiest task!) as well as taking the time to get to know us and what we wanted. He did a truly wonderful job capturing our outdoor wedding. His work is natural not just in how he works with the natural surroundings and lighting, but also in capturing so many great candid moments of us for our film. He even took the time to sit down and interview our family and friends to film sentimental clips of them sharing heartfelt stories about us and wishing us the best, (especially on such a busy day when we didn't get to spend tons of time individually with all of our loved ones) we can hear what they would have liked to say to us on our wedding day, lol. When we look at the films he created for us, we are instantly swept up in re-living that day. I would wholeheartedly recommend Brent to anyone looking for an excellent luxury videographer!
Michelle L., a year ago
Quick responder
New Jersey Wedding Studio 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $2,100
  • Serves Valley Stream, NY
  • Offer

New Jersey Wedding Studio is a full-service Wedding Videography & Photography studio based out of Cedar Grove, NJ. We specialize in artistic cinematic and documentary wedding video coverage in New Jersey, New York, Connecticut, and Pennsylvania. We are passionate about creating beautiful wedding videos that at the same time capture the true atmosphere and emotions of the most important day in your life!

Awarded Best of Zola
My experience with New Jersey Wedding Studio was great! From the initial consultation to the final product delivery, every step was marked by professionalism, creativity, and enthusiasm. What truly sets New Jersey Wedding Studio apart is Frank's dedication to creating a personalized experience for every client. He took the time to listen to our vision, offered valuable insights, and suggestions along the way while remaining receptive to our input. The result? A collection of photos and videos that not only met but exceeded our expectations. Frank excels in customer service. Communication was prompt and clear, and deadlines were consistently met without sacrificing quality. They went above and beyond to accommodate our requests, ensuring that every aspect of our wedding photography and videography was nothing short of perfect. I cannot recommend New Jersey Wedding Studio highly enough. If you're looking for a wedding photo & video studio that not only captures moments but creates memories to last a lifetime, look no further. They are storytellers, capturing love and celebration in every frame.
Nenad, 9 months ago
Quick responder
Instillwonder 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $1,850
  • Serves Valley Stream, NY

Your Love Story is waiting to be told: Imagine your wedding day, immortalized in a cinematic narrative that unfolds like a professional movie. Our skilled storytellers capture everything - the laughter-filled aerial shots, the intimate whispered promises, even the subtle, blink-and-you-miss-it moments that truly define your day. We're there when you're getting ready, capturing the anticipation in the air. We're there as you exchange your vows, documenting every tear and every smile. And we blend in during your reception, discreetly capturing the pure, unscripted joy of your guests.

Awarded Best of Zola
We just got our wedding film back from InstillWonder and are in awe. Andrew and his assistant didn’t just film our day, they told our story. The way they captured the energy of the wedding including the drone shots of our venue were breathtaking. Can’t recommend him enough for capturing the essence and emotion of our wedding day! Hire him!
Mackenzie B., 10 months ago
Quick responder
Mist + Moss 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $6,500
  • Serves Valley Stream, NY

Hi, I'm Chad. My goal is to create something captivating that you can cherish for a lifetime, while at the same time giving you and your guests an amazing experience. My films are tailored to you, authentic to your story and your wedding.

Awarded Best of Zola
We hired Mist Moss to cover our June wedding and were blown away by our wedding films. We received a 3 minute teaser a few weeks after the wedding and then a longer video a couple months after. Both film were absolutely incredible. Chad captured our wedding so beautifully and truly showed the love, happiness and fun of the day perfectly. We could not have asked for a more special way to remember our wedding day forever. Not only is Chad extremely talented, but he is also so kind and considerate and was such a pleasure to be around the whole wedding day. We absolutely recommend Mist Moss to any couple looking to be in love with there wedding film forever.
Abby, a year ago
Quick responder
Fen Video Production 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $1,200
  • Serves Valley Stream, NY

Hello! My name is Fen, nice to meet you online! I’m a freelance cinematographer and editor. I split my time between shooting weddings and indie films. I enjoy doing both because I love the thrill of operating a camera and I love people and stories! I have shot over 300 weddings and I edit everything myself. In my spare time I love swimming, hiking, skiing, traveling with my family, writing and learning all kinds of stuff. I’m very curious about the world!

Awarded Best of Zola
Fen shot our wedding in October 2019. When I tell you I watch our wedding video and to this day cannot pick out a single moment Fen missed, I’m not exaggerating. She did an amazing job, captured our day perfectly and I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend her to any family member or friend looking for a videographer. Truly an artist!
Vin & T., 4 years ago
Wedworkflow Videography 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $2,000
  • Serves Valley Stream, NY

Hello, Lovebirds! My name is Max! Congratulations on your upcoming wedding! At Wedworkflow Videography, I believe that every love story deserves to be cherished for a lifetime. Your wedding day is a treasure trove of emotions, and I am committed to capturing those fleeting moments in the most authentic and unobtrusive way possible. Whether it’s the tears of joy in your eyes, the laughter shared with loved ones, or the heartfelt vows exchanged, we will be there to immortalize every precious instant. I am thrilled to be a part of your love story!

Max was nothing short of amazing right from the beginning. I wanted a videographer- my husband didn't want the extra cost. I had already reached out to Max, but when my husband said no, Max was kind and understanding and not pushy or salesy. I ended up overriding my husband last minute, as I was afraid I'd regret not having video, and thankfully Max still had our date available! He ALWAYS responded quicker than almost all of my other vendors, and was so easy to work with! Our big day came, and Max worked so seamlessly with every other vendor. He captured EVERYTHING I wanted and more. He got amazing behind the scenes shots, all of the little details, and every emotion of the day. We just got all of our footage, and it brought both my husband and I to tears. Max captured so much more than I realized, we were truly able to relive our big day. His editing is EXCEPTIONAL and seriously better than I ever could have imagined, he really blew our minds. My husband is now thankful I went ahead and booked video- my ONLY regret is that I didn't have Max stay for the full (or most of the) reception, and he left after our first dance, cake and speeches. He seamlessly put together the most amazing highlight video that captured every important moment and blended everything together so well and chose the perfect song for the background. I debated on asking him to use our song for the background music, but I am so glad I left everything fully up to him to piece together at his discretion. You seriously cannot go wrong with him, and I very highly doubt you'll find a better videographer in central PA. I honestly cannot thank Max enough for capturing our day the way he did, and for the amount of time, thought and skill he puts into his passion of videography.
Sarah R., 8 months ago
Quick responder
Margo Sees Stars 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $4,900
  • Serves Valley Stream, NY

Hi! I’m Julia, middle name Margo, a film school dropout and music buff who wants to make your wedding look like art. I'm here to represent diversity in the couples I work with and weddings I shoot (love is love), to give you something hyper-shareable that will instantly transport you in space and time for the rest of your lives, and to make you cry upon watching. The crying is very important. Bear with me on this analogy, but basically I like my wedding films like I like my salads: raw, organic, a little bit of quirk and flare, and consumed alongside great music. If this sound pretty good to you, have a look at my work and get in touch!

Awarded Best of Zola
We were on the fence about getting a videographer, partially because it seemed unnecessary and partially because we were worried that we would feel uncomfortable having a camera follow us around. But we met with Julia (Margo Sees Stars), and ultimately decided it was worth the risk. We could not be happier! Although Julia herself was booked for our wedding day, her colleague Mel was fantastic--she was friendly, unobtrusive, worked great with our photographer, and really put us with ease. And Julia's editing ability is off the charts. We opted for the package with a short teaser as well as a longer video, and both brought us to tears. We are so happy that we went with Margo Sees Stars for our special day. You will not be disappointd if you do the same!
Emily, a year ago
Quick responder
Kane Films, LLC 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $900
  • Serves Valley Stream, NY

Hey there! Looking for top-notch photo and video services in CT, MA, NY or RI? Look no further than Kane Films, LLC! My name is Harry Kane, and I am the creative force behind this awesome company. At Kane Films, we specialize in capturing the most important moments in life through our photography and videography services. Whether you're looking for a talented wedding photographer to capture your special day or a skilled videographer to create a touching wedding video, we've got you covered.

Awarded Best of Zola
Harry made it super easy for us to add last-minute video coverage for our wedding. He communicated well and got great footage of the wedding day. He was very receptive to our wants and needs, including feedback after he made our preliminary video. We are so happy with our wedding day video and cannot thank Harry enough!
Casey S., 2 years ago
Quick responder
Films by Nadia 

4.7

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $1,600
  • Serves Valley Stream, NY

Born and raised in Ecuador, Nadia Belen moved to New Jersey at age 8 where she was raised in a cultural melting pot within close proximity to New York City. Straight out of college, she became part of a wedding collective in the New York metropolitan area as a videographer in 2019. Currently residing in Los Angeles, Nadia continues to focus on capturing raw and organic moments in everyday life through street photography, music videos, and of course wedding films.

Nadia captured our wedding day with the exact energy I was looking for! She took the important details that I was interested in (candid family-oriented shots) and blended them into a 10 min TREASURE that I will never stop watching. Her smile is contagious and her communication following our wedding was impeccable. So grateful for this forever memory of our day!
Emily, a month ago
Quick responder
First Day Films 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Serves Valley Stream, NY

First Day Films was started with one goal in mind: to tell our clients’ stories as elegantly and unobtrusively as possible. Our films capture the events we cover precisely as they happen. Nothing artificial, nothing cheesy. We have all been to events where the video crew are the most noticeable people in the room. The bright lights, the uncomfortable interview requests… Our team of videographers believe that distractions like these put you and your guests on the spot. So we do our best to avoid them entirely.

Awarded Best of Zola
John and his team are a true pleasure to work with. They pay attention to what matters most to you and then deliver videos that really highlight those moments. We are so happy with how everything turned out--our videos are a perfect reflection of our wedding day!
Sara, a year ago
Quick responder
Humblebee Wedding Films 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $3,997
  • Serves Valley Stream, NY for additional fees

Hello couples and congrats on your engagement! My name is Mike and I am the founder of Humblebee Wedding Films. We love filming with emotion which is why weddings are one of our most favorite live events to document. We have been filmmakers for many years but just started filming weddings in 2021. From our very first wedding we knew that this was going to be our calling. I tell all my couples, if I am getting teary-eyed while editing your wedding film...I know I'm doing it right! I can't wait to talk with you about how we can make magic together. P.S. We are a firm believer in equality and inclusion. Love is love!

Awarded Best of Zola
We had an absolutely seamless experience with our wedding videographer from start to finish. The entire process was easy, and on the big day, they were so discreet we hardly noticed them—yet the amount of stunning content they captured was truly remarkable. The videos they produced allow us to relive our wedding day again and again, and each time it brings back the same emotions. Choosing them was the best decision we made, and we highly recommend them to anyone looking for a professional and talented videographer!
Joe L., 3 months ago
Quick responder
Perfect Cadence Events 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $2,500
  • Serves Valley Stream, NY for additional fees

Perfect Cadence Events offers an unobtrusive style of videography that provides full coverage of your days events while you enjoy the company of family and friends. We strive to capture even the small, genuine moments to be enjoyed for years to come. Options include highlight (5-10 minute), full-length (1-2hr) and short feature (30 minute) edit profiles. Ask about drone coverage in your area!

Awarded Best of Zola
We hired Perfect Cadence Events for our wedding in June 2024 for videography and DJ and we are so glad we did. Logan, the owner, was our videographer and he was so professional, kind, and great to work with. He is super quick with communication, answered all of our questions, and he made sure to ask the right questions to capture our wedding day the way we wanted. On our wedding day, he gave us some advice and helped calm our nerves, he was so friendly. We did a ceremony video and a highlights reel and added on toasts. They were all so great and I can't wait to watch them every year on our anniversary. A lot of my friends told us they wished they had a videographer at their wedding and I can see why. It will be so great to have these memories to watch over and over. Then we had Mike as our DJ and he was great to work with. We had a couple of phone calls and they use an online platform to ask you questions and to put in must play songs, etc and it was awesome to have because it made sure we didn't forget anything and that we had everything we wanted. I highly recommend Perfect Cadence!
Sara, 5 months ago
Quick responder
Motel Cinema 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $5,000
  • Serves Valley Stream, NY for additional fees

Fueled by nostalgic recalling we aim to create a film that is timeless and authentic. Motel Cinema is based out of San Diego, Ca and our approach to weddings is inspired by the untraditional travelers before us, who hit the road in search of adventure into the unknown. We don't like boxes and we don't want wedding films that fit into one. If that tickles your fancy let's get weird.

Awarded Best of Zola
One of the best decisions we made for our wedding was to hire Motel Cinema! As an entertainment marketer, specifically for documentaries, how our wedding would be documented was top of mind for me and I met with quite a few videographers. Brandon completely exceeded my expectations with the moments he caught on film, the editing, the music, the vibe. I really felt like he saw us and reflected it all back to us in the most special way which we will cherish for the rest of our lives. He was an absolute joy to work with through the entire process- easy to communicate with and quick, but also a relaxed energy that fit seamlessly into our wedding weekend. I cannot recommend Motel Cinema enough and I’m so so grateful that we were connected.
Joelle, 6 months ago
Quick responder
Purple Thistle Films 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $2,000
  • Serves Valley Stream, NY for additional fees

Hi! I am a documentary wedding filmmaker and award winning documentary filmmaker, shooting digital and Super 8 film. I am also a birth doula/photographer (remember me down the road!), and bring a sense of calm, groundedness and an appropriate level of assertion to wedding days. I consider weddings exciting opportunities to step into communities and make something beautiful that reflects exactly who people are and their experience. Get in touch if you are in search of an artist with great instincts who can encapsulate your day authentically, reflecting the spontaneity of the moment. Happy to travel for an aligned vision. Love all love.

Awarded Best of Zola
We are so thankful for Amanda’s attention to detail, kindness, and beautiful video storytelling. She was with us to document our entire wedding day, and provided a ceremony edit & raw footage a couple months later. I’d highly recommend Amanda if you are looking for a videographer who genuinely wants to help create something beautiful for your special day! Thank you, Amanda!!!
Lilli J., 2 months ago
Quick responder
Hereafter Films - Wedding Photo & Video 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Serves Valley Stream, NY for additional fees

Hereafter is a wedding production house of talented videographers & photographers serving the Pacific Northwest & Central Texas. Throw out the stress of formulaic & performative weddings. We want you to have an experience-driven, true-to-you celebration with cohesive & creative wedding photography & videography to remember it all. When your veil flies in your face, when you wipe your tears on your sleeve, when you dance until you can't breathe, that's where we thrive. When you trust us to capture those real and honest moments, you end up with photos & video about your love that transcend time.

When my fiancé and I were searching for wedding vendors, Hereafter Films stuck out to us. I immediately looked at their Instagram feed and their website and I was in awe of the quality of their work. You can clearly see how much love they pour into their brand and every video I watched made me feel all sorts of emotions. We met up with Sharayah and Ryan (pre-pandemic) to get to know them and we were so impressed with how in sync they are. They genuinely want to know your vibe, your relationship, and what you want captured on your wedding day. We wanted our video to feel genuine and intentional, not posed and stiff. It wasn't until I saw our wedding video that I extremely appreciated the time they took listening to our needs because they checked every. single. box. They captured every raw emotion we felt and so many small details we didn't see day of because everything moved so fast. Sharayah and Ryan were so easy to work with day of, they made sure we felt relaxed and unposed! They were everywhere but simultaneously they weren't in the way. We were so impressed with how well they worked with our photographers as well, they made an amazing team! We'll cherish our highlight and heirloom videos for years to come. We'll be watching them over and over again reliving the best day of our lives.
Kristen & K., 4 years ago
Quick responder
Visil Videography 

4.3

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $1,950
  • Serves Valley Stream, NY for additional fees
  • Offer

Hey, I'm Victor Silas, the heart and lens behind Visil Videography. As the owner and lead filmmaker, I'm deeply passionate about storytelling and capturing love stories on film. It's not just about recording moments; it's about documenting a moment you will relive. Our film style is documentary-style; we use sound, capturing all the laughs with your bridesmaids when you're getting ready, to the moment you see each other for the first time, your vows, and speeches from your wedding party to tell your story.

Henry was great to work with! He made us laugh and came up with fun angles. I so look forward to seeing our video!
Dakota S., 2 years ago
Quick responder
Mawaddah Productions 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $5,000
  • Serves Valley Stream, NY for additional fees

Mawaddah Productions a women-owned videography company who has been dedicated to artistic and authentic storytelling worldwide for years. Specializing in wedding cinematography, Mawaddah Productions delicately crafts documentary heirloom films for romantics.

Awarded Best of Zola
My husband and I spent months looking for the perfect videographer for our wedding- since we are both creative people, we wanted someone who values storytelling, has a documentary style that captures the real emotions of the day, and cares deeply about their craft. Talking to Saja felt like finding our creative soulmate, because she goes above and beyond on all of these fronts. She is incredibly detail oriented and has an incredible eye for elements you might not think of as a bride and groom. And to top it all off she’s super down-to-earth and was so fun to work with day-of. I can’t recommend her enough!
Sarah Q., a month ago
Quick responder
Wedding Love Film:Bridal Video 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $1,500
  • Serves Valley Stream, NY for additional fees
  • Offer

Hi there! I'm Anthony Hagen, the creative behind Wedding Love Film. Having filmed over 350 weddings, I specialize in capturing real, candid moments with a cinematic touch. Whether you're looking for all-day coverage or a shorter, intimate edit, I offer customizable packages that fit your budget and vision. I focus on telling your unique love story through film—one you'll cherish forever. Not sure what coverage you need? I’m happy to guide you every step of the way! Let’s connect and create something beautiful for your big day. Reach out today to discuss your perfect wedding film package.

Awarded Best of Zola
Anthony was easy to work with at the wedding. I was a DJ at the wedding I worked with him and from an artistic standpoint, what I saw of his work so far was great. Just like the rest of the vendors at this wedding, he went with the flow and went above and beyond to give the couple the best experience they could get especially under the crazy weather circumstances we had! Rain almost all day, thunderstorms, a tornado warning (it was an outdoor tent wedding) and some high winds that almost took out the tent! Despite that, he remained positive and fun. His needs from me were minimal (tapping into my sound system) and he made sure I wasn't busy when he asked me about it. If the rest of his work is as good as the little I've seen so far, you can't go wrong with his video service!
Todd K. O., 7 months ago
TrendlineTrending
Dianna Nguyen Films 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $4,950
  • Serves Valley Stream, NY for additional fees

When inviting me in to tell a part of your story, you are letting me into your relationship. No matter the session, elopement, or wedding, I will capture without reserve everything from the smallest details to the greatest landscape; so when you return to this story you will feel everything. From the last light on the horizon to the messy and playful love, your film will hold memories, not just videos.

Awarded Best of Zola
We had the absolute best time working with Dianna from start to finish! She was detail-oriented, creative and shared my artistic vision. From our phone conversations to the day of the wedding, my husband and I were delighted to have her with us. We were delivered a 30 minute wedding video that we will cherish forever.
Megan W., a year ago
GemHidden gem
KS Media Productions 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $1,850
  • Serves Valley Stream, NY for additional fees

Based in Southern California - filming wherever your love goes. With 5 years as a professional videographer, I discovered a passion for filming weddings and documenting moments that’ll last forever. I have a background in video production and as a colorist as well as a degree in Film Production from NYU.

KS Media Productions were an absolute delight to work with for our wedding videography. From the start, their communication was always punctual, professional, and courteous. Kristi and Karina were amazing to collaborate with - they meshed so well with our photographer and made the entire experience 10 times better. My husband is usually quite shy, but they made him feel completely comfortable and relaxed in front of the camera. The final product they delivered was truly top-notch and so heart-warming. Kristi was also incredibly responsive throughout the process and captured our wedding day perfectly. We could not be happier with the magical highlight video they created for us. Highly recommend KS Media Productions to any couple looking for exceptional videography for their special day!
Mk V., 8 days ago
GemHidden gem
BENJAMIN THOMAS FILM 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $4,000
  • Serves Valley Stream, NY for additional fees

My name is Ben. I am a LA-based Wedding Filmmaker who runs on emotion-driven films that tell the story of you as a couple. The wedding day for sure! - But lets be honest, the wedding day is only whatit is because of who you are together before and after the day is done. Let's get some of that. That's the stuff that lasts longer than a few years after your wedding. The stuff your kids will pull out and watch.

Awarded Best of Zola
Ben's work speaks for itself. He captures beautiful stories and presents them in a way you never thought possible. You'll laugh, you'll cry and you'll find yourself saying things like "Dang, we look so good!" - because you'll feel like movie stars. And while you'll feel like Hollywood royalty, you won't have to worry about the paparazzi cramping your style - Ben's subtle and intuitive work flow captures all the important moments without ruining the vibe. He's easy to get along with, he knows what he's doing, and his films allow you to revisit your special day as often as you'd like. TL;DR Felt like movie stars, everything looked amazing, book Ben: A fun, creative & artistic professional.
RYAN & D., 3 years ago

Location flexible? Discover videographers near Valley Stream, NY

About wedding videographers in Valley Stream, NY

How much do couples typically pay for wedding videography in Valley Stream, NY?

In Valley Stream, NY, wedding videography ranges from $500 to $10,000 and averages at $3,000. The cost reflects the videographer's ability to capture and edit the footage of your special day.

Do most videographers capture drone footage?

91% of videographers in Valley Stream, NY have Drone capabilities!

Which are the most popular videographers in Valley Stream, NY?

Some of the most popular videographers in this area include Ledd Lens LLC, Photo and Film (Video Listing), Eivan's Photo & Video and Pluvia Studios.

What's the most common type of deliverables for videographers in Valley Stream, NY?

Most videographers offer a Highlight reel or Short feature deliverable.

What types of videographers are in Valley Stream, NY?

What other Valley Stream vendors will I need?

What other videographers are nearby?

What other wedding services are nearby?