The Best Sugar-Free Wedding Cake Bakeries in Stratford, NY

The Best Sugar-Free Wedding Cake Bakeries in Stratford, NY

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


5 Wedding Cakes & Desserts in Stratford, NY

Sugar-free
Quick responder
Gallagher's Catering Sweets 
Rating: 5.0 (2 reviews)
  • Starts at $80
  • Serves Stratford, NY
  • Offer

Why Choose Gallagher’s Catering Sweets? For four years, Gallagher’s Catering Sweets has been creating custom wedding cakes and desserts made to be as unique as each couple. From elegant wedding cakes to cupcakes, stuffed cookies, dessert tables, and custom favors, we bring creativity, quality, and personal service to every celebration. We proudly serve Schoharie, Delaware, Greene, Otsego, Montgomery, Schenectady, Rensselaer, and Herkimer Counties. Let us make your special day a little sweeter!

“From the start, Gallagher's Catering Sweets was so easy to work with. We weren't sure how to describe what we wanted, but they understood perfectly and made our cake exactly right. The brothers went above and beyond to set everything up on time and better than we expected. Our guests couldn't stop talking about how delicious the desserts were—the rich flavor and perfect sweetness really impressed everyone. It's clear these two young adults take real pride in their work, and we're grateful they started this business as teenagers and keep improving. We'll definitely be supporting them for years to come and recommending them to anyone looking for incredible desserts.”
Joseph, a month ago
Quick responder
Rosebloom Cakes 
Rating: 5.0 (8 reviews)
  • Starts at $500
  • Serves Stratford, NY for additional fees

I'm a former costume designer and fashion historian with a PhD in English literature, now using my love of art, craft, and design to create one-of-a-kind custom wedding cakes! I make delicious, colorful cakes in traditional and modern flavor combinations, topped with handcrafted sugar flowers. I use only the highest-quality ingredients and always emphasize both design and taste. I would love to work with you to make your cake one of the most memorable and beautiful parts of your wedding!

Awarded Best of Zola
“Abigail was so amazing to work with from start to finish. My husband and I usually aren’t big cake lovers but this cake was the exception. We gave her some ideas for flavors and what we usually gravitate towards and she made our cake into three tiers with two different flavor combinations that were out of this world. She also worked with us on the design to make sure it was exactly what we wanted. The sugar flowers matched our wedding flowers perfectly and our guests couldn’t believe they weren’t real. Everyone raved about how delicious it was and we were able to save the top tier for ourselves. Couldn’t recommend her enough!”
Alanna S., a year ago
Lucifly Cakes 
Rating: 5.0 (13 reviews)
  • Starts at $800
  • Serves Stratford, NY

Creating a high-quality, stunning cake is what motivates me in the kitchen. Of course, a cake should taste just as delicious as it looks! I hope for the design of my cakes to inspire joy and wonder, and the eating of them to make people smile. Nothing makes me happier than delivering clients their dream cake!

Awarded Best of Zola
“Working with Lucy was a dream! I had a vision in my mind of what I was looking for -- something over the top, sparkly, glamorous, and -- of course -- delicious!! With very little direction, Lucy went ahead and created the cake of my dreams. It was beyond delicious (highly recommend the banana cake) and I was thrilled when I showed up to my wedding and saw the cake I had envisioned come to life. Can't wait to find another excuse to work with Lucy!”
Catherine E., 5 years ago
Shae's Cakes 
Rating: 5.0 (1 review)
  • Starts at $1
  • Serves Stratford, NY

Hello! My name is Shaelyn Oathout. I am the self taught one woman show behind Shae’s Cakes, an in-home bakery based in Poland, NY. I’m so glad you’re here! Shae’s Cakes started early in 2020 as a hobby, but I quickly realized just how passionate I am about starting from scratch, and bringing people’s sweet dreams to life! I look forward to getting to know you, and helping you create tasty memories that will last a lifetime!

“Shae’s Cakes made cake pops for our wedding. She made 4 different unique flavors, and they were the most delicious cake pops I’ve ever had! People still talk about them over a year later! It makes a huge difference knowing that the dessert served at my wedding was rememberable. We will be using Shae’s Cakes for all of our events in the future! She is very easy to work with and accommodating.”
Andres & B., 5 years ago