The Best Sugar-Free Wedding Cake Bakeries in New Windsor, NY

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


11 Wedding Cakes & Desserts in New Windsor, NY

Sugar-free
GemHidden gem
Sweetbakes Cafe 
Rating: 5.0 (2 reviews)
  • Starts at $300
  • Serves New Windsor, NY

Sweetbakes was founded from humble beginnings: a mother taking time from her career in nursing to provide her children with unique birthday cakes. With growth in creativity and skill, and a supportive family dedicated to the success of the newfound business, Sweetbakes Cafe was born.

“You cannot go wrong with Sweetbakes! Jenny Jordan is kind, professional, thoughtful, and creative, and her story is so inspiring! I have enjoyed her cakes for several birthdays and special events, including my cousin's gender reveal party, and they're always delicious and built to perfection. She's super flexible and can really make your cake ideas come to life. And she really is so versatile: she can make something elegant and refined for your wedding, or something fun and wacky for your bachelorette. She's making my 3-tier wedding cake and she's been communicative and collaborative throughout the whole process. On top of that, she's got a really cute cafe in Wappingers with coffee and all sorts of baked goodies. I can't recommend her enough, it's been a joy to support this local female-owned business!”
C & J., 6 years ago
Quick responder
Sugar Crystles 
Rating: 5.0 (31 reviews)
·Ratings include Zola and Google reviews
  • Starts at $4
  • Serves New Windsor, NY

Sugar Crystles is a wedding confectionery company in New Milford, CT. This budding bakery is owned and run by me, Crystle, and I am industry professional with years of cake-making in my repertoire. Using my skills, I do my best to craft stunning wedding cakes and delectable desserts that will have you and your guests wanting more. I create a variety of desserts and cakes for any special occasion with various techniques. From icing-covered sugar cookies to a variety of desserts for a buffet, I do it all. I also specialize in gluten and dairy free. I will cater to any flavor or design of your choice. Cake tastings are also available

Awarded Best of Zola
“Crystle was wonderful to work with. She has so many different options and we were so happy with all the desserts and our guests are still talking about the cake pops! We had a cake for my husband and I and it was absolutely amazing. I couldn’t recommend her desserts more!”
Olivia C., 22 days ago
Quick responder
Rosebloom Cakes 
Rating: 5.0 (8 reviews)
  • Starts at $500
  • Serves New Windsor, NY

I'm a former costume designer and fashion historian with a PhD in English literature, now using my love of art, craft, and design to create one-of-a-kind custom wedding cakes! I make delicious, colorful cakes in traditional and modern flavor combinations, topped with handcrafted sugar flowers. I use only the highest-quality ingredients and always emphasize both design and taste. I would love to work with you to make your cake one of the most memorable and beautiful parts of your wedding!

Awarded Best of Zola
“Our wedding cake was an absolute showstopper-- the flowers perfectly matched the ones I carried and were incredibly gorgeous/life-like. In addition, the cake was delicious and beautiful. Roseboom Cakes went above and beyond in working with me to create a cake that was visually stunning and matched the wedding decor with astute attention to detail. In addition, Abigail is a delight to work with and will make sure you have the cake of your dreams!”
jackie, 2 years ago
Quick responder
Gallagher's Catering Sweets 
Rating: 5.0 (2 reviews)
  • Starts at $80
  • Serves New Windsor, NY
  • Offer

Why Choose Gallagher’s Catering Sweets? For four years, Gallagher’s Catering Sweets has been creating custom wedding cakes and desserts made to be as unique as each couple. From elegant wedding cakes to cupcakes, stuffed cookies, dessert tables, and custom favors, we bring creativity, quality, and personal service to every celebration. We proudly serve Schoharie, Delaware, Greene, Otsego, Montgomery, Schenectady, Rensselaer, and Herkimer Counties. Let us make your special day a little sweeter!

“From the start, Gallagher's Catering Sweets was so easy to work with. We weren't sure how to describe what we wanted, but they understood perfectly and made our cake exactly right. The brothers went above and beyond to set everything up on time and better than we expected. Our guests couldn't stop talking about how delicious the desserts were—the rich flavor and perfect sweetness really impressed everyone. It's clear these two young adults take real pride in their work, and we're grateful they started this business as teenagers and keep improving. We'll definitely be supporting them for years to come and recommending them to anyone looking for incredible desserts.”
Joseph, a month ago
Quick responder
Little Treats and Cakes by Janna, LLC 
Rating: 5.0 (9 reviews)
  • Starts at $360
  • Serves New Windsor, NY for additional fees

Little Treats and Cakes by Janna specializes in wedding cakes and specialty cakes for all occasions. Our commitment is to create an original piece of edible art, that it’s not only beautiful but also very delicious. We not only offer cakes but also a variety of treats for your event like custom cupcakes, sugar cookies, and a full dessert menu which is created to match the theme and design of your event for an unforgettable sweets table. We also offer guest edible favors. At Little Treats and Cakes by Janna we also offer gluten free, dairy free and vegan options if you have dietary restrictions.

Awarded Best of Zola
“Working with Janna at Little Treats and Cakes was a game-changer for our wedding day. She responded quickly to every question and made the whole process feel collaborative and stress-free, which meant we could focus on other details instead of worrying about desserts. Janna took our vision and turned it into gorgeous cakes and mini bites that tasted as good as they looked and fit our theme perfectly. Her desserts were delicious and she clearly put thought into every detail. She also made us a gorgeous anniversary cake! If you want beautiful, flavorful desserts without the headache of planning them yourself, Janna is your person. We couldn't have asked for better service or a sweeter experience working with her.”
Arielle I., 2 months ago
Shae's Cakes 
Rating: 5.0 (1 review)
  • Starts at $1
  • Serves New Windsor, NY

Hello! My name is Shaelyn Oathout. I am the self taught one woman show behind Shae’s Cakes, an in-home bakery based in Poland, NY. I’m so glad you’re here! Shae’s Cakes started early in 2020 as a hobby, but I quickly realized just how passionate I am about starting from scratch, and bringing people’s sweet dreams to life! I look forward to getting to know you, and helping you create tasty memories that will last a lifetime!

“Shae’s Cakes made cake pops for our wedding. She made 4 different unique flavors, and they were the most delicious cake pops I’ve ever had! People still talk about them over a year later! It makes a huge difference knowing that the dessert served at my wedding was rememberable. We will be using Shae’s Cakes for all of our events in the future! She is very easy to work with and accommodating.”
Andres & B., 5 years ago