The Best Wedding Cake Bakeries in New Albany, IN

The Best Wedding Cake Bakeries in New Albany, IN

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads?


25 Wedding Cakes & Desserts in New Albany, IN

Quick responder
Maddie About Cake (MAC) 

5.0

  • Starts at $66
  • Serves New Albany, IN

Maddie About Cake is a micro-bakery based in Louisville, KY, specializing in French macarons. We help our customers access high-quality French macarons in a variety of unique and unexpected flavor combinations.

Maddie is incredible to work with and her macarons are literally the best in the Ohio valley region, if not the best in the entire United States. She takes great care and pride in her work and her product is really like nothing else! From dessert tables or favors at weddings to corporate gifts or private parties and everything in between, Maddie is the best of the best. I highly recommend her as an addition to your wedding or event!
Allison Warnersmith, 9 months ago
Quick responder
Tastee Treats Louisville 

5.0

  • Starts at $250
  • Serves New Albany, IN

I spent 20 years in the corporate world as a Graphic Designer, and baking was something that I always gravitated to when I felt stressed out. During the pandemic, I found myself in the kitchen a lot. I was constantly trying out new recipes and techniques, growing my arsenal of skills, and learning how to batch bake. I also spent that time setting up my business one block at a time, slowly creating a solid foundation of clients like you that enjoy what I make just as much as I do!

Tastee Treats Louisville provided us with a beautiful, delicious wedding cake that exceeded our expectations. The communication with them was easy and responsive, and they truly brought our vision for the cake to life. The cake was not only gorgeous, but also incredibly delicious - we were extremely happy with how it turned out. Tastee Treats went above and beyond to make our special day even more memorable. We highly recommend them to any couple looking for an exceptional wedding cake experience.
Monica S., a month ago
TrendlineTrending
Bae's Baekery 

5.0

  • Serves New Albany, IN

Bae’s Baekery™, LLC began in January 2019 when Abigail Mattingly was gifted a Kitchen Aid mixer for the holidays. She had baked her entire life, but was allowed to explore more avenues previously unavailable upon receiving the mixer. She was already baking for family and friends throughout the holidays, but began to crank out more products, including cookies, eclairs, bagels, and other pastries, and was advised continuously to begin selling her products.

Bae's Baekery has been my go-to for all our special occasion desserts ever since I first discovered their amazing cookies years ago. The communication with the team is always quick, timely, and very detailed - they make the ordering process a breeze. But the real star is the quality of their work and the taste of their desserts. The attention to detail is phenomenal, and their cakes and pastries are absolutely delish! I'm so thrilled to see Bae's Baekery thriving and I will continue to buy all our special occasion sweets from them. Our wedding day cake was better than I could have imagined!! The cookie butter flavor we chose was just the icing on the cake
Morgan J., 4 days ago
Quick responder
Simply Sweet Ice Cream Catering 

5.0

  • Starts at $525
  • Serves New Albany, IN

I have a super cute ice cream cart! I would love to be your dedicated server on your special day! Offering over 70 premium ice cream flavors including gluten free, reduced fat/no sugar added, and non dairy addition options! Best selling flavors: Chocolate, Moose Tracks, Cookies and Cream, Green Mint Chip, Strawberry, Vanilla, Cappucino Crunch, and Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough! My business is based in Clinton, TN but serving surrounding counties and states. I am licensed and insured! I look forward to serving you and your guests!

Anita arrived early, served ice cream quickly and efficiently and was great to work with! I had so many compliments of her stand and the flavors. The stand was adorable and blended in so nicely at the wedding. Perfect for a hot day!
Sydney C., 3 months ago
Two Sons Cakery 

5.0

  • Serves New Albany, IN

We are a certified, appointment-only cake studio located just south of Bloomington, Indiana. With award winning cakes, Two Sons Cakery provides an unforgettable experience by inspiring a culture of pride and customer satisfaction. Creating top quality, imaginative, and delicious baked treats, we make sure to respond positively to the needs of the community. Whether you’re looking for a simple naked cake or something more creative and unique, we’ve got just the thing for you!

We trusted Two Sons Cakery to help us design our wedding cake. From the cake tasting to the delivered product on our wedding day, we couldn’t be more pleased. Amanda is so much fun to work with as her creativity and artistic talent really shine through on her cakes. Our wedding cake was no exception. She knew how to make the design I had in my head come to life in the cake. From a communication stand point, Two Sons Cakery has a high level of professionalism that is very much appreciated when planning a wedding. Response time to questions were answered quickly and communication was always thorough and clear. Our cake was delivered over an hour away and everything looked beautiful! We highly recommend Two Sons Cakery and all they have to offer for any occasion you are planning. You will not be disappointed.
Zach & K., 4 years ago
Quick responder
Sweet Buckets 

5.0

  • Starts at $300
  • Serves New Albany, IN for additional fees

We began as a concession company providing cotton candy at sporting events. In the fall of 2021, we extended our brand by starting our own manufacturing plant. Sweet Buckets was born as an option for customers and businesses to purchase Cotton Candy and Gourmet popcorns direct from our company.

Awarded Best of Zola
We had our wedding reception at a brewery and wanted some easy to eat sweet and salty snacks. These popcorn flavors were delicious, they sent us flavors to try before we decided. We chose 4 flavors and they shipped them right to our house. The popcorn buckets had our cute custom labels which they designed for us and looked PERFECT! We had tons of compliments on the popcorn. We ordered plenty and people were grabbing them to take home at the end of the night. A perfect snack after a few beers. Theu were very fast with the samples and the order too!
Lyndsey C., 5 months ago
TrendlineTrending
Lil' Bit of Heaven Cupcakes LLC 

5.0

  • Starts at $500
  • Serves New Albany, IN for additional fees

My name is Teri Blevins and I am the ridiculously proud Owner of Lil' Bit of Heaven Cupcakes ❤️ Lil' Bit of Heaven Cupcakes is the longest, single owned Cupcake Bakery in the state of WV, proudly baking your dreams come true for almost twelve years! We bake for and deliver 60 weddings every year on average, and we deliver weddings up to 6 hours away. Weddings are my biggest responsibility (failure is NOT an option) and also my biggest blessing ❤ We were voted by WV WEDDINGS MAGAZINE readers as the BEST WEDDING CAKE IN WV for 2021, and have been voted the BEST HOMETOWN BAKERY IN WV by MSN, and consistently named the BEST CUPCAKES IN WV ❤

I worked with Teri last year for an August wedding and she was such a treat! Then I had some of her desserts - mouth wa-te-ring! I'm a huge sweets person, and I loved that their cake was sweet but not overly done.
CJ Scott, 4 months ago
TrendlineTrending
BakerBitesCo 

5.0

  • Starts at $200
  • Serves New Albany, IN for additional fees

Ready to impress your guests with our unique tasty treat? BakerBitesCo offers single serve fudge bites with customized labels to fit your perfect day. Wedding favors, bridesmaids gifts, wedding party gifts, etc. these can be used in any way to fit your needs. WHY YOU'LL LOVE US -We offer delicious unique seasonal flavors -We ship anywhere in the US -We can send a sampler box so you can taste all our flavors and pick your favorites. -Budget friendly at only $2/piece -Prepackaged, making our dessert ideal during COVID -We give a meal to a hungry child with every order We can't wait to make your day even more spectacular!

Best fudge I’ve ever had and the flavor varieties are amazing! I love that I can customize them for any occasion!
Linda, 4 years ago

Location flexible? Discover cakes & desserts near New Albany, IN

About wedding cakes & desserts in New Albany, IN

How much do wedding cakes usually cost in New Albany, IN?

Wedding cake packages start at $200 and run up to $200 per person in New Albany, IN.

Do bakers in New Albany, IN offer cakes for special diets?

They do! 15 offer Gluten-free desserts, and 11 offer Vegan options.6 offer Sugar-free options.

What are the most popular cake and dessert options in New Albany, IN?

The most popular wedding cake vendors in New Albany, IN are Tay’s Sweet Shop, Sweet Buckets and Lil' Bit of Heaven Cupcakes LLC.

What other New Albany vendors will I need?

What other cakes and desserts are nearby?

What other wedding services are nearby?