Sarah likes to tell people that they met at the Rangers v Capitals hockey game in NYC when they actually met the night before at a club called Riff Raff (RIP). Charlie immediately fell for Sarah and was fortunate to bump into her again the following night at the hockey game before heading out of town for the Christmas Holiday. He continued to pursue her until she finally agreed to visit him in grad school at William & Mary and, as they say, the rest is history!