We often disagree on when we met and how. Ed remembers hitchhiking from Duluth to Bemidji only to arrive at a party at Grace's cabin at the request of his best friend Amos. He walked in to see Grace baking baguettes, fairly intoxicated, and she asked him if they were too salty, which they were. Grace remembers walking in to his house in Duluth, to pick up his roommate Luke, to find Eddie shirtless and doing pull ups in the kitchen. It was love at first sight.