Andrea and Corey met in November 2014 and started dating in December 2014. Their first date was hanging out at Great Lakes Crossing mall and seeing The Hunger Games: Mockingjay Part 1 in theaters. Corey waited until the right time to pop the question, including after Andrea graduated law school and got settled in working as an attorney...and during a pandemic quarantine! To pass the time, Corey asked Andrea if she wanted to play The Game of Life and watch a movie, to which she agreed. Corey then proceeded to burn popcorn in the microwave, leaving the kitchen with a burnt popcorn smell for the next week. However, in spite of that, Corey turned on The Hunger Games and started playing the game. When Corey got to the "Get Married" space, while Andrea was trying to get a girl piece for him to put in his little car, Corey snagged Andrea's girl piece from her car and put it in his, saying "I already got my girl." Then he got down on one knee and asked Andrea to marry him. And obviously, she said yes!