Craig's Cake Shop
Price per serving
Starts at $2 per person.
About Craig's Cake Shop
Craig's Cake Shop
Delicious recipes and a dedicated team in Verona, Wisconsin Founded in 2000, Craig’s Cake Shop is a commercially licensed bakery with a long history of baking memories in the Madison area. We are honored to be part of your life’s precious milestones — from weddings to birthdays and everything in-between, you’ll never meet a team more passionate about the power of a perfect dessert. Life is short. Let’s make it sweet — together.
Our delicious cakes, mini cakes, cupcakes, and other desserts have been hand-baked and decorated to perfection. We’re proud to be famous for our signature frosting and time-tested recipes. While we put countless hours of heart and soul into each cake’s design, their rich texture and mouth-watering flavor always come first. It’s our goal to create desserts that both look and taste amazing. What’s more — we use only buttercream frosting for all of our cake designs. This means every mouthful is delicious, and you’ll never have to choose between a perfectly smooth fondant-style finish or a frosting that you’ll actually enjoy eating.
Services
Dessert types
- Cakes
- Cupcakes
- Donuts
- Mini desserts
- Novelties and other
Decor options
- Cake toppers
- Custom text
- Fruit topping
- Sugar flowers
Available customizations
- Cake filling
- Cake flavors
- Cake frosting
Services offered
- Consultations
- Delivery
- Setup
- Tastings
Dietary accommodations
- Dairy-free
- Gluten-free
- Nut-free
- Vegan
- Vegetarian
Reviews
Write a review4.7 out of 5
3 reviews
Stunning delicious Wedding cake
Craig's Cake Shop was an amazing vendor to work with for our wedding. Their communication style was truly amazing - they were extremely responsive and did exactly what I wanted. The quality of their work and the value was also amazing. The 4-tier pearl design cake they created was absolutely stunning, and the taste was out of this world. Everyone at our wedding raved about how delicious the cake was - there was no need for any other desserts when the cake tasted that good! I would 10/10 buy from Craig's Cake Shop again and highly recommend them to any couple planning their wedding.
Delicious Cake
Craig's Cake Shop was a delight to work with for our wedding cake and cupcakes. Throughout the planning process, Craig communicated in a timely and helpful manner, answering all of our questions with care and providing suggestions when needed. The final products were not only delicious but beautifully decorated as well. They were able to accommodate our request for gluten-free cupcakes alongside the wedding cut cake. We would highly recommend Craig's Cake Shop to any couple looking for a baker who provides excellent service along with baked goods that look and taste incredible.
Delicious Cake
I recently had my wedding 11/11/23. The cake was absolutely delicious. Everyone loved the cake and raved about it. I'm still getting messages about how people loved the cake. We had three different flavors for each tier and each one turned out perfect. I would highly recommend for the taste alone. The cake was simple, but pretty. The branch design matched my centerpieces which added to the overall theme of my wedding. The downside was the process. We didn't get to see our cake until we walked into our venue on our wedding day. Our cake toppers weren't on the cake, which was a bummer. We had some hiccups during the order with a lost deposit and the wrong flavors being written down. It didn't ruin the experience, but it did make things difficult to give them a glowing review. But even with all that, we are excited to get our anniversary cake from them next year!
Explore other vendors serving Verona, WI
- Degroot Film Co
- LUXE Sunless Studio
- Veiled Rose Films
- Something Borrowed Blooms
- Developing Diamonds Photography LLC
- Musical Genius Productions
- Party Boy Audio
- Marc & Mindy
- Tavern Team WI
- Eric Turner Photography
- Victoria Mcdonald Photography
- Polished Entertainment
Complete your dream team
- Verona Venues
- Verona Photographers
- Verona Beauty Professionals
- Verona Bands & DJs
- Verona Florists
- Verona Caterers
- Verona Planners
- Verona Videographers
- Verona Bar Services & Beverages
Other cakes & desserts in Verona
Other wedding services nearby
- Madison, WI Wedding Bar Services & Beverages
- Watertown, WI Wedding Bands & DJs
- Janesville, WI Wedding Caterers
- Beloit, WI Wedding Photographers
- Watertown, WI Wedding Florists
- Beloit, WI Wedding Bar Services & Beverages
- Janesville, WI Wedding Planners
- Sun Prairie, WI Wedding Venues
- Beloit, WI Wedding Videographers
- Madison, WI Wedding Venues
- Beloit, WI Wedding Bands & DJs
- Sun Prairie, WI Wedding Bands & DJs