The Best Wedding Venues in Shelter Island, NY

The Best Wedding Venues in Shelter Island, NY

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


10 Wedding Venues in Shelter Island, NY

The Boathouse Shelter Island 

5.0

Shelter Island, NY
  • Up to 200 guests
  • Raw space
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $15,000

The Boathouse Shelter Island is a private event space located on Shelter Island at the Island Boatyard and Marina. The recently renovated, 4,000 square foot space features over 200 feet of waterfront and incredible sunset views overlooking West Neck Harbor. The historic building, dating back to the 1920's, was originally used as boat storage. Today, it debuts a new look with versatility for any stylish event. Grammy award winning musician and East End resident Billy Joel recorded his album, River of Dreams, at The Boathouse in 1993.

Working with Megan and the boathouse team was a dream. They're attention to detail and willing to work with us as a couple and our vendors was unmatched. The venue itself is the perfect place to plan a wedding. It's a blank slate and so working with our event designers, we were able to create the most incredible reception space with views of the bay and a cocktail party that our guests are still talking about to this day. If I could relive our day at the Boathouse I would do it over and over again. I recommend this venue and the team that supports it to anyone who is looking to host a wedding out on long island or Shelter Island in particular.
Sarah, 5 years ago
TrendlineTrending
Hotel Moraine 
Greenport, NY
  • Up to 100 guests
  • Raw space
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $1,500

With breathtaking views of the Long Island Sound, our property offers 20 guest rooms, a sprawling lawn, private beach, pool, and bluff cottage. We host events for up to 100 people. Tented Events on the Lawn: Our expansive lawn overlooking the Long Island Sound provides the ideal setting for tented events of up to 100 guests. Say "I do" with the gentle sound of waves and the sun setting over the water as your backdrop. Private Bluff or Beach Ceremonies: Exchange your vows in an intimate ceremony against the backdrop of our private Bluff or Beach areas. The serene atmosphere and natural beauty of the surroundings will enhance the magic of the moment. Special Requests & Intimate Dining: We take pride in accommodating your special requests to make your event uniquely yours. Our Cottage on the Bluff offers an intimate space for rehearsal dinners or private dining experiences for up to 25 guests, adding a touch of exclusivity to your celebration.

Quick responder
The Halyard at Sound View Greenport 

5.0

Greenport, NY
  • Up to 180 guests
  • All-inclusive
  • Outdoor
  • Starts at $4,500

A home for weddings, celebrations, or the perfect sound side cocktail party, Sound View Greenport is the newly renovated, boutique Resort on the North Fork, with the ability to host events up to 200 guests (with a full venue buyout) or a small intimate wedding in our Library room, up to 50 guests. The convivial atmosphere and timeless charm of our spaces and grounds will provide you and your guests with memories to last a lifetime. Whether it is saying “I Do” on our private beach or celebrating a bridal shower or rehearsal dinner in our cozy library, our catering team is on hand to create a tailor-made event for your enjoyment. The Halyard can accommodate a seated wedding with dance floor for up to 130 guests and can offer a cocktail style reception for larger groups up to 150. Create the wedding weekend of your dreams.

After visiting The Haylard, my then-fiancé and I knew it was the perfect wedding venue! From the location, to the food, to the staff, everything contributed to make it the most special day. Caroline is truly amazing and made sure every last detail was coordinated so that we did not need to worry in the slightest on the day of. She is beyond thoughtful and put so much care into making sure our day was perfect (even despite a last minute move to an indoor ceremony). Nothing missed a beat. Our guests told us countless times during and after the wedding that it was the best wedding they had every been to, that it was the best wedding food they had ever been to and they couldn't stop raving about Greenport and the Halyard. There is not enough space to say all the wonderful things about the staff and the venue that I would like to, but my husband and I could not recommend the Halyard more. It was a perfect day! We're ready to do it again!
Tessa, a year ago
Calissa Restaurant 

5.0

Water Mill, NY
  • Up to 400 guests
  • Select services
  • Indoor & outdoor
  • Starts at $10,000

Calissa is Mykonos in The Hamptons. Drawing on a decade of private dining experience in Manhattan and The Hamptons, our events team executes dynamic, unique and creative events with professionalism and care. Calissa’s outdoor dining spaces include the tented Garden, covered Terrace and open-air Meadow. Our more intimate indoor spaces are the Private Dining Room, Lounge, Bar, and Main Dining Room. We recommend utilizing either the two outdoor spaces or renting out Calissa in its entirety. Services Offered In addition to weddings, Calissa is available for bridal showers, engagement parties, rehearsal dinners, farewell brunches, and afterparties. Food comes first for us: we serve the same ingredients to private dining guests as are served to a la carte guests, sourced from family-run farms and local fishing boats. We are Slow Food certified and have won numerous awards for our commitment to sustainability.

Calissa was amazing! We booked our wedding ceremony/reception and they were all so accommodating. The restaurant/venue is beautiful on its own, so we didn’t need much for flowers and decor. The food was delicious, our guests said that food kept coming and that’s exactly what we were looking for. And the service was excellent. Everyone was so attentive and friendly. From the planning of the day’s events, including the amazing band, to the food and the details, Calissa was amazing. Several of our guests said our wedding was the best ever! Dara and Kylie were amazing! Our day was perfect!
Anita S., a year ago

Location flexible? Discover venues near Shelter Island, NY

About wedding venues in Shelter Island, NY

How much do wedding venues typically cost in Shelter Island, NY?

The cost of a wedding venue varies widely by location, number of guests, and many other details of the wedding package. Shelter Island, NY offers a range of options that can fit most budgets. Raw venue space rentals (which only include the space itself) start at $1,500 and average $9,000. All-inclusive packages start at $120 and average $10,000.

What types of venues can I find in Shelter Island, NY?

Shelter Island offers a wide range of venues, including Ballroom, Beach and waterfront and Hotel and resort.

What are some of the best wedding and reception venues available in Shelter Island, NY?

Some of the most popular venues in this area include The Halyard at Sound View Greenport, Bourne Mansion and Stonebridge Country Club. But just like finding "the one," finding the perfect wedding venue takes time and a little bit of magic. Start by envisioning your dream wedding - the ambiance, style, and location. Then, explore our extensive collection of carefully curated wedding venues. Our marketplace provides detailed information, stunning photos, and real couples' reviews to help you make an informed decision. Trust your instincts, and when you find that venue that gives you butterflies, you'll know it's the one.

What questions should I ask when booking a venue in Shelter Island, NY?

It all depends on what you're looking for, but you may want to consider things like whether the venue has an on-site bridal suite (52% in Shelter Island do) or whether the venue provides an event coordinator (41% in Shelter Island do!).

Additionally, some venues work with certain caterers and require a minimum food and beverage spend in addition to the space rentals. Others might have a recommended list of preferred caterers that they'd like you to work with.

Can the venues in Shelter Island, NY accommodate both small and large weddings?

Of course! Small wedding venues in Shelter Island, NY can host intimate parties while large venues can accommodate up to 1000. The average venue in Shelter Island can seat 150 guests.

What amenities do the reception venues in Shelter Island, NY offer?

The venues in Shelter Island, NY are known for the exceptional suite of services and amenities offered to couples and their wedding parties. The most common services provided are Wheelchair accessible, Bar services and Service staff. Some venues even offer Transportation!

What types of wedding venues are in Shelter Island, NY?

What other Shelter Island vendors will I need?

What other wedding venues are nearby?

What other wedding services are nearby?