While a visit to Starbucks helps ensure job security for Emily, if you're looking for a caffeine fix with more of a local flare we recommend Pegasus Coffee. It's an iconic piece of Bainbridge Island's rich tradition and a local landmark, operating since 1980. This ivy-covered coffee haven was the first coffee roaster to serve espresso over the counter in the Seattle area and the lattes served today still use the original espresso developed more than 40 years ago.
If you're making a weekend of it and have time for a meal a bit off the beaten path (will be a drive away from the ferry terminal and downtown area), we highly recommend Via Rosa 11. You'll experience some authentic Italian cuisine and a charming ambience. (Get the lasagna!)