On the night of New Year's Eve and Kaleb's birthday, we went to what I thought was a birthday dinner. Kaleb's brother-in-law, Adam, drove us to The Cavalier in Virginia Beach for a delicious meal and drinks. We celebrate NYE with his family every year and Kaleb's birthday most of the time gets overshadowed. This year Adam said he booked us a dinner reservation at The Cav as Kaleb's birthday gift. Very believable! After about 2 hours at dinner it was time for the last course... Our waiter walks over with a plate of dessert and the words "Will You Marry Me?" were written on it. As soon as I finished reading, I looked up and Kaleb was on one knee in front of the whole restaurant. I was in shock for about 15 seconds and then finally realized this was real life! I said "YES", we shared a kiss, and everyone around us was clapping and spreading their cheer! We came back to celebrate with both families and had the best night ever