Carl asked Mary's Father (Bob) to meet for dinner at The Smith in Midtown before a Ranger's Game. As soon as they sat down, Bob said "I know why you asked me to dinner and my answer is yes!". Then he immediately called his daughter to congratulate her, before Carl actually popped the question. Mary waited for her moment. The next night, Carl asked Mary to have dinner alone at their favorite place. As the sun set, Carl proposed in their backyard next to the pool, alongside their dogs Mia and Lincoln. Mary said YES, and it was the most perfect night.