John and Caitlin met in May 2019 at a mutual friends house. After coming back from different concerts, Black Dahlia Murder (John attended this show, obviously) and Vein, Cait woke John from his slumber in the living room of their friends' house with her rambunctious and fun loving personality. A great night was had but in the morning it was seemingly not meant to be given the long distance between them. However despite John not being Cait's type initially (due to his beard), scrolling through Instagram, she saw he had liked one of her photos and she slid into the DMs.... on more than one occasion until he got the hint. Shortly after, they went on their first date at Tattooed Mom, attending a hardcore show at TLA in Philly followed by an “everything sandwich” at Jim’s steaks. The relationship started long distance with Cait in Baltimore, shortly after moving outside of NYC for work, and John in Jenkintown, but the surprise of the 2020 was COVID - that’s when their relationship truly blossomed. With so many relationships ending over this time, Cait and John’s got stronger after they shacked up at the beginning of the pandemic. They moved in together in John's mojo dojo casa apartment, rented their first house together shortly after, and eventually bought their first home in Westville, NJ in 2021. The love John and Caitlin share for their dogs, Bravo television (john is coming around) music, sports, and the outdoors make them a perfect match.