A date here locked it in for us! This sushi is exceptional and there are several locations in Manhattan. Note that you cannot make a reservation, so should only choose this if you have time and inclination to wait a bit.
For those of you who dream of pastrami
Leah's favorite pizza
Insufferably snooty, no seats to be had most of the time, but one of the best croissants in the city and excellent coffee
They only take cash!