On January 2nd of 2020, Colt sent Kaitlyn an Instagram DM that said "Hey boo, you're cute can I get your snap?". They went on their first date January 4th of 2020 to Outback and the movies. They started officially dating January 10th of 2020, and they have been together ever since!
Colt was invited to play in the Arizona Fall League in 2022. Kaitlyn flew out to visit him in Arizona a few days before games would start. The two of them went on a date to Culvers followed by watching the sunset over a golf course. While at the golf course, Colt popped the big question, and Kait obviously said yes because you are reading this today!