Holly and Justin first met at an friend's housewarming in Hoboken, New Jersey. Their first date was during a blizzard, and the restaurant that Justin made a reservation at was closed for the storm. The two still had their first date but went to Cadillac Cantina which many of the Hoboken locals would cringe at. No surprise it is no longer open. The rest is quickly history. It was only appropriate that on May 26th, 2023, Justin got down on one knee in the couples beloved Hoboken, NJ.