At San Gennaro's Feast in 2012, we met for the first time. Gary told Frank he thought that girl Jenine was pretty cute, but Frank had failed to mention that was his sister. We all should have known then how the rest of this would play out. A few years later Jenine joined the Mannasquan house with Gary, Frank, Danielle and Andrew and it was hard for Gary to ignore the chemistry he sensed with Jenine. Unreciprocated interest is an understatement. Gary tried to gain favor by helping Jenine with cutting fruit for the sangria. He was chastised for not having any skills with a knife and sent out of the kitchen. A few months later Jenine came to her senses. Maybe it was lust, maybe it was rebellion, but she asked to meet up with Gary to hang out. We don't know where that night went, but when it was over everyone else was gone from the bar and the rest of our lives had already started without us even knowing.