A party on Fire Island. Mutual friends. Very unclear flirting. Twelve years and many adventures later, it's a lot clearer!

During a trip to Montauk, NY in 2021, Jay decided to walk the dogs along the beach and Eric insisted on coming along. All alone by the ocean in the gorgeous morning light, Eric popped the question! The dogs were THRILLED - as was Jay. We laughed, kissed, got our feet wet, and wondered what gay couples got for engagement jewelry. We're still wondering.