Jake rented the entire Campus Theatre in Lewisburg to ask Gabby to marry him. He worked with a videographer and wrote 366 reasons he wanted her to be his wife. The list took him over two months to create. The day of the proposal, he took her to a nice restaurant for lunch before going to the theatre to "watch a replay of the movie 'Ghostbusters.'" After playing the ads for Ghostbusters, the screen opened to reveal the actual proposal video. Jake proposed to Gabby onstage with a one-of-a-kind ring he helped design.