Erin swiped right on Jake because he had red hair, of course. She was living in Brooklyn and he was living in Jersey—but their offices were just close enough that their Bumble locations overlapped. And surprise! They were both from the same area of Pennsylvania and loved musical theater. The two met at one of Erin's favorite bars near Union Square in Manhattan, The Belfry, where they promptly took pickleback shots. After a few hours of chatting nonstop at the bar, they moved across the street to another NYC favorite, Artichoke Pizza, where they shared a slice of the least healthy piece of pizza in the world. The evening ended at the top of the stairs down to the subway stop at 1st Avenue and 14th Street. Jake leaned in for a kiss and the rest is history.