Our first date spot! The food was only okay, but we can't *not* include this place in our roundup
Get the lobster mac & cheese. You won't be disappointed.
The best pizza on Long Island, according to Elissa. Order a side of fried cappellini and thank me later
Elissa's favorite diner. Tina's, too ♥
Hands down the best bagels in NYC
The sandwiches are amazing, but we can't express how much we love the chipotle mayo. We'd buy it by the gallon if we could
Jason's go-to Greek joint for gyros
The best place for a late-night sandwich. Warning: this place is always poppin' no matter the time of night so you might want to call in your order ahead of time
Jason's favorite pizzaria in Queens