Eugene downloaded Tinder and met Cathy one year later. The evening before their first date, Eugene met a woman at a Mexican restaurant and she refused to eat guacamole. So there was no way that was going to work. He didn't have high hopes for Cathy, so he reached out to her to confirm their date. He secretly hoped that she would cancel - she did not. Cathy downloaded Tinder and met Eugene one month later. Eugene was Cathy's first Tinder date. Once the date was set, she thought it was odd that he texted mid-week to "just say hi" and to repeatedly confirm their date, even up to the last hour. She thought, "what a weirdo," but went ahead with the date. They met at Kashkaval in Hell's Kitchen and there was instant chemistry. Not even five minutes in, they were already making plans for date number two. One week later, they went bowling and Cathy rolled a 115, beating Eugene. From there on out, they spent nearly every day together. Since then Eugene and Cathy have adopted Chewie, who destroys their stuff but is the other love of their lives.