Caitlin and Pearce met while working at Chick-Fil-A in their late high school and early college years. Caitlin fell in love with the Texan and continued to pursue him after several failed attempts. Finally, Pearce gave in and the couple made it official in January of 2017. They began living together at the end of 2018. Caitlin and Pearce were engaged by the summer of 2020. Their daughter, Evelynn, was born in February of 2021 and they welcomed their son, Lucas, in June of 2023. Caitlin and Pearce eloped July 27, 2023 and intend to celebrate their marriage with family on their one year anniversary.