Madison knew Conner was the one by the end of their first date. He brought her pre-rehearsal pizza (an ENTIRE pizza that she could then share with the rest of the costume shop) and they talked about Ted Bundy and the subsequent Zac Efron movie. A week later, Conner made Madison's whole costume crew a Neopolitan cheesecake and brought her a liter of Topo Chico. They've been inseparable since.