In December 2019 Bethany and Morgan decided to go on a girls trip to visit their friend Amber, who had recently moved to Denver, CO for New Years Eve. The day before NYE the girls went on several brewery tours and Amber told them she had some men that she had invited to NYE. Amber believed at least one of these men would be perfect for her friends and started to describe one of the guys. She said Josh was tall, cute, in finance, and played hockey. Bethany immediately called dibs. It turned out Amber was texting these men and when Bethany heard this she drunkenly exclaimed "tell him I have 3 pairs of ice skates and I like stocks and bonds." Flash forward to NYE, the girls met Amber's boyfriend (at the time) and his eligible friends Seth and Josh for dinner before heading to the bar. Bethany was so embarrassed by her drunken remarks the day before that she sat across the table from Josh and said very little throughout dinner. The girls proceeded to go out to a bar for NYE's and the boys remained at their house. After the bar, the girls returned to the house and with a little liquid courage Bethany and Josh began interacting more. A game of cards against humanity, a foot massage, and a steamy goodnight kiss was all it took.