To this day, Cole Chesnut and Katlyn (DeVoe) Langmeier argue who gets credit for introducing Cade and Bethany. It was spring of 2016, and Bethany found herself heading to Mother's Pub on a Tuesday with Katlyn. Katlyn said they were meeting with friends (Cole, Cade, and others) just getting out of wine and spirits class (actually a legitimate college course). Turns out, Cole and Katlyn both knew the couple separately and thought they might be a good match. Cade bought Bethany a drink and they continued meeting at Mother's on Tuesdays (with Katlyn and Cole). Cade graduated that spring and the couple started their four to six hour long distance relationship. Cade surprised Bethany April 16, 2021, with a ring, and the couple is excited to begin their journey together hand in hand.