While Andy had been back in the dating world for a short time, Bailey was just starting to date again after the pandemic and decided to make a Match.com profile. That day, maybe 10 minutes after Bailey completed her profile, Andy found her and they instantly started chatting. Less than a week later, Bailey and Andy met for their first date. They met at a coffee shop and went to the park where they would eventually have their first kiss, get engaged, and walk their dog frequently. Shortly after their first date, Bailey and Andy realized they had aligned goals and were both looking to settle down and eventually get married. They bonded over their love of wine, food, being outdoors, spending time with family, and antique shopping (ok, maybe Bailey influenced Andy a little here). As they became closer and Andy spent more and more time at Bailey's house, he started to do research on the piano she let the previous owners leave at her house. Turns out, it wasn't worth much, and it would cost a lot of get rid of. So what was Andy's suggestion? Turn it into a bar! While transforming the piano, Andy was able to spend more time with Bailey's dad and unknown to Bailey, this was when Andy asked Dan if he could marry Bailey. Then when the bar was complete and a party for close friends and family was planned, Andy had a surprise in store. As Bailey regularly does, she started the day with a manicure and brunch was planned with friends who came in from out of town. Andy met Bailey for coffee after her manicure and suggested a walk in the park where they had their first date (on a cold January morning), and Bailey suspiciously agreed. While walking in the park, Andy got down on one knee and Bailey said, "Yes"! A few months later Andy and Bailey adopted their four legged son, Miller and he is so excited for his mom and dad to get married!