Forget Me Not Cake Shop, LLC


Price per serving

Starts at $7 per person.


About Forget Me Not Cake Shop, LLC

Forget Me Not Cake Shop, LLC

Cottage Home Cake Shop

Three generations ago, my wife's great-grandmother owned a bakery in New Jersey. Now, 100 years later, we created our cake shop. We honor our family by offering some signature cakes, such as Teapot's Tea Party, an Earl "Gray" tea cake with lemon filling and lavender frosting. Our passion is to create realistic floral cakes which are not only gorgeous but taste incredible. Each color palette is custom mixed to each client's exact needs. Our cakes feature two frostings to add texture and flavor variation. Our cakes have various flavor undertones to create depth.

We will only focus on one cake order at a time per weekend. This allows us to give each order the priority that each couple's wedding or shower deserves. We work with each client to ensure that the color palette is perfectly suited for your special day and custom mix all the colors per order. As our goal is to create realistic flowers and succulents, we will consult with you on the types and sizes of flowers, and how they will be incorporated into the unique style of your wedding reception or shower. Our signature meringue frosting pairs perfectly with the frosting of the flowers offering a beautiful texture.

Best of Zola 2025
Best of Zola 2023

Services

Dessert types

  • Cakes
  • Cupcakes

Decor options

  • 3D sugar work
  • Cake toppers
  • Sugar flowers

Available customizations

  • Cake filling
  • Cake flavors
  • Cake frosting

Services offered

  • Consultations
  • Delivery
  • Setup
  • Tastings

Dietary accommodations

  • Gluten-free
  • Vegan

Reviews

Write a review

5.0 out of 5

7 reviews

Write a review
  • Amazing!

    •Verified review
    •Erica•Dec 30, 2024

    I had used Forget Me Not last year for my wedding, and Tamara was incredible to work with! So kind and offered so many different options and worked so well with me and my husband and even made a delivery all the way to Palm Beach Gardens. The cake tasted amazing and looked gorgeous, and she was very accommodating with helping me find the perfect color palette and design. There was so many customization options and the tasting was so fun! My family loved the cake too and I'd recommend her to anyone!

  • The best!

    •Verified review
    •Ashley•Oct 2, 2024

    Tamara was an absolute godsend for our March wedding. My husband and I are vegan and I also needed the cake to be gluten free. She worked with us to find a solution that worked for our dietary needs and our budget. Everything from the planning process to the tasting to wedding-day coordinating was an absolute joy. Cannot recommend this cake shop enough!

  • customer

    •Verified review
    •Sarah D.•Sep 25, 2024

    Tamara outdoes herself every time! Her cakes are works of art and she is my go-to for any and all special occasions. Her creations are just as delicious as they are beautiful!

  • Unforgettable cakes

    •Verified review
    •Samantha•Sep 25, 2024

    I have had cakes made for the last three birthdays I had for my children. These cakes are not only SO delicious but also beautifully designed. At each child’s birthday party my guests even request to take left overs of the cake home. Tamara is an amazing artist and really takes into account who she is making the cake for. She asks for theme, taste profile and a little about their personality to make it truly personalized. The entire process is so easy and helps to alleviate one less stress when throwing a party. I will never get a cake from anywhere else. (Captain America cake was taken after my son ate one of the eyes)