The Best Sugar-Free Wedding Cake Bakeries in West Lafayette, IN

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


5 Wedding Cakes & Desserts in West Lafayette, IN

Sugar-free
Quick responder
Tay’s Sweet Shop 
Rating: 4.6 (37 reviews)
  • Serves West Lafayette, IN

Bringing my passion to life, I specialize in made-from-scratch desserts. I’m a home-based Vendor in Noblesville, IN where small businesses are the heart of our community! I opened in 2017 as part time and took it on full time during the pandemic, after having my daughter.

Awarded Best of Zola
“We had Tay's Sweet Shop create our wedding desserts and couldn't be happier with how everything turned out. Their team was quick and easy to work with from start to finish, and they delivered right on time without any stress. The cakes and desserts held up perfectly in the heat on our wedding day, which was a huge relief since we were worried about everything melting. Our guests couldn't stop talking about how delicious everything tasted, and we got compliments about the desserts all night long. If you're looking for a dessert vendor, we highly recommend trying her carrot cake with the maple frosting it was absolutely incredible. You won't regret choosing Tay's Sweet Shop for your wedding!!”
Mariana S., 2 months ago
Quick responder
The Basement Bakery 
Rating: 5.0 (12 reviews)
  • Starts at $3
  • Serves West Lafayette, IN for additional fees
  • Offer

I am a home baker who specialized in decorated sugar cookies, cakes, and small desserts. I would love to help make your special day magical! I work a full time job and bake on the side with a dream of one day being able to open my own bakery!

Awarded Best of Zola
“The Basement Bakery was an absolute pleasure to work with for our wedding. Their communication throughout the entire process was fantastic - they were responsive, flexible, and made sure we felt taken care of every step of the way. On the day of the wedding, the set up was seamless and the desserts they provided were out of this world. Our guests raved about how delicious everything was, with many saying it was the best wedding dessert they had ever had. We are so grateful to the team at The Basement Bakery for helping make our special day even more perfect. Would highly recommend this bakery for any events you have coming up.”
Megan, a year ago